Work Text:
The night was like every other for Stu and Billy. Another sleepover at Stu's house, her parents were not present as always. Billy knew how lonely she was in the big house, so she just kept coming back. Making the taller girl cling even more to her. She found it irritating at first, but after a while of knowing each other and getting closer with each day, she got used to it. Stu was weird, eccentric and pure annoyance sometimes, but she shared with Billy the love for scary movies. So they spend most of their time watching and talking about said movies.
Showing each other every new scary movie they would find. They both had their favourite movies, but finding new ones meant new thrilling experiences. New ways the killers in them spilled blood, new ways they tortured their victims. It was all just exciting to see. Both got off to those things. It would have been strange and gross to anyone else, but not to them. Finding someone as weird, that feels pleasure from seeing killers massacring their victims was nearly like finding your soulmate. Making them both even more stuck by the other's side. Both twisted in their own ways, finding comfort in someone else that was as odd as they were.
Laying comfortably together in Stu's living room. The movie was a low hum, its light was the only thing illuminating the whole room. Both girls were located on the couch. Stu's legs thrown over Billy's lap while she laid watching the movie. It was one of her favorites, blood was splashing every 5 minutes, it made her so happy to see it.
Billy's mind on the other hand was somewhere else. Just a few days ago she found out that her father had an affair with her boyfriend's mother. It made her so mad, she saw red. No wonder her mom just left one day and never came back. Every victim in the movie that was playing in her mind, turned into that whore that destroyed her family or even her pitiful son. For past days she has been only thinking about murdering them both. Planning everything out to look like it was someone else, to not connect her with this. It was all getting too much, how can she kill them alone and not get caught? She needed to add something to the plan.
“Something is on your mind? You've been glaring at the tv more than usual” Stu's voice broke between the victim's screams on the screen, also making Billy get back to reality from her thoughts. Her empty gaze moved to look at the girl laying on the couch. Thanks to the movie’s lighting, she saw the faint smile on the girl's face waiting patiently for any answer to the question. Her playful demeanor and presence might have looked crazy for anyone else in the situation, but for Billy it looked perfect. It suddenly all clicked in her head. The missing piece to her masterplan was the supporting killer, someone who wouldn't be connected that easily and someone she could rely on for a valid alibi, and that great accomplice role can go to Stu.
Stu comes off for many as just an airheaded, silly girl, but behind it all she was sharp and had a pretty sadistic nature. You can learn a lot about a person when they show you their favorite horror movie and go on a rant about how better it would look with real blood and deaths. So now obviously she was the best choice for the role of the second killer.
Their relationship was weird. Both wouldn't fully call it love; it all was more like an obsession thing rather than love. Just two people finding solidarity in their kind of psychotic natures. No one really questioned them about how close the “friendship” was, why would they honestly? Both had boyfriends like the society wants, so it doesn't matter that they fool around with each other more often than care about said boyfriends. It's normal for girls to be more touchy, right?
With each sleepover they got bolder. It started with small touches like laying on each other, holding hands, sleeping with arms around the other girl, but it quickly escalated to something more rough, more daring. Making out with Halloween playing behind their backs. Each of their high moans played in perfect sync with the screams of pain from the victims on the screen.
“I have been thinking about something that we can do together,” said Billy, shooting Stu a grin and slowly pushing her legs so she can situate herself between them. The brunette had a clearer look of the other's face. “You know, something more thrilling than watching those horror movies,” she added. She saw a flash of curiosity on her face before going for their first kiss of the night. Their kisses were always messy, wet and passionate. Always leaving them gasping for more.
The kiss breaks for a moment; both girls were trying to catch their breaths. Billy's hands start roaming lower and under the other's shirt. Squeezing her breasts and teasing her nipples, making Stu whimper with each touch. Her face twisting in pleasure. “So what more thrilling is on your mind?” she breathlessly asked, struggling to keep her eyes open and focused on the girl on top of her.
One of Billy's hands slipped even further down her body. Going down her abdomen and traveling slowly even lower. Her hand stopped on Stu's thigh. Her fingers pushed her sleeping shorts and panties aside, giving herself perfect access to her heat. Teasing her clit and opening, making Stu whine with anticipation.
“We should make our own horror story in real life” she said with a devilish grin, pushing swiftly between the other’s folds without warning one of her fingers. Stu’s face morphed into a silent scream. She threw her arms around Billy's neck, pushing their faces even closer.
Their lips connected in short kisses. Billy's gaze never left the other's face. Seeing every twist of pleasure; her soft grin, making her look like a pleased cat.
“We can torture my boyfriend's family, kill his mother wait a bit and kill more people” Billy said quickening her finger's movement. Shock flashed for a second in Stu's for a second, she didn't expect the plan to play around that guy. She knew Billy played with him, but never really did much. He was a great guy but a bit boring. They probably kissed like three times. Stu felt superior to him in this region. Claiming Billy before him or anyone else.
“Throw some big party, kill him and his close circle, and blame it all on his father. Giving it all a mentally unstable father killing his family and people adjacent twist” she continued with her plan. Making sure to angle her finger in a way that made the other moan louder. She could feel her getting wetter with each mention of the crime.
“We can just stab each other shallowly, smear some blood on our faces, and play perfect scared little victims surviving” while saying that she pushed in a second finger, making Stu grin wider. She was truly a freak that gets off thinking about ending someone's life just for the fun of it.
“And everyone will believe us, because we are just some young girls who can do nothing wrong” Billy's fingers started to pick up quicker pace. She could feel her partner's excitement with it all. Stu pushed them into a sloppy kiss. Billy bit her lip which drew a moan out of the girl beneath her. She smirked and lowered herself next to her ear.
“And if you want we can even play with your ex boyfriend and that new little girlfriend of his” she whispered, her fingers going even faster with each moment. Wicked smile matching Billy's forms on Stu's face. Her moans and whines getting higher. Billy could tell she really liked that idea.
All that talking and fingers hitting her sweet spot felt so intense. It made Stu's mind feel so fuzzy. Her lover kissing and biting on her neck didn't help. She was nearing her release. Her body started to twitch. Billy let out a laugh seeing her body acting like this.
With one particularly hard thrust; Stu came screaming Billy's name. Breathing quickly, she clenched on the fingers inside of her. Billy stilled her motion letting her calm a bit. She took out her fingers, covered with the other's release. She looked straight into her half open eyes when she licked it off her fingers. It made Stu blush and cover her eyes with hands. Billy just smirked at her.
From their little moment they broke out, because of screams and loud noises coming from the movie on the screen.
“Boo we missed my favorite part” Stu said with the pout moving her head to look at the television. The movie was near the end, they missed half of it because of their little heated moment. Billy could only giggle at her. She was truly amazing. Her lover just proposed killing people, telling her the whole plan and she is thinking about their background noise? How odd she is.
But Billy still needed to know “So are you in?” she asked, kissing the other's cheek to make her look her in the eyes.
Stu grinned and said: “With you? always”