Work Text:
Toni was always a top.
She liked being a top.
She had been a top in all of the four relationships she's had and she didn't think dating Shelby would be any different. They have slept together quite a few times already. She, as usual, topped and had Shelby in all the positions she could possibly dream of. They had the perfect dynamic, at least that's what Toni thought. She didn't think Shelby had any problems with only her topping until they were laying in bed one night cuddling after hours of fucking and having Shelby shaking beneath her until she was begging for a break.
"So, I was wondering about something..." Shelby said suddenly as she finally caught her breath and turned her head to look at the brunette laying next to her.
Toni hummed in response, feeling the body next to her starting to shuffle closer. She lifted her right arm above her head to let Shelby's warm body settle into her side, feeling her leg draping across her waist as she nuzzled her nose into the crook of her neck. She couldn't help but to let out a small chuckle at the tickling sensation, her fingers lingering down to trace circles across her shoulder blade.
Shelby let her fingers play with the sports bra still covering Toni's breasts. Toni was always so hyper focused on Shelby; getting her undressed, fucking her and making her feel good that she oftenly was left still half undressed by the time the blonde had already come undone at least three times. "Do you- I mean..." she took a small pause as she tried to figure out how to word herself. "Do you not want me to, like, you know... Do you?" she slapped herself mentally at how she asked this in the most insecure and confusing way possible.
"You have done me, babe," Toni replied calmly as she switched to stroke her palm across her skin. "I came like ten minutes ago."
The blonde let out a small laugh as she pulled back to look up at her girlfriend. "You used my thigh, Toni... I wouldn't exactly say I 'did' you in the way I was referring to."
"What way were you referring to?"
Toni wasn't stupid. She knew exactly what way Shelby was referring to, she felt her hands start to sweat by just the thought of it. She loved sex. She absolutely fucking loved sex and she didn't mind having Shelby touch her, but she preferred being in charge of the way she was touched. Giving up control and letting someone else do whatever they wanted to her body scared her, but what terrified her was that the other person wouldn't be able to satisfy her and she would have to fake it. She didn't want to put poor Shelby through that.
Shelby tugged lightly at the strap of the brunette's sports bra as she lifted her eyebrow. "I just want to make you feel good, Toni," she said in a sultry voice. She leaned forward to drag her lips up her girlfriend's neck, loving how her body responded to her. "I can feel the way your body reacts to my touch," she whispered as her lips trailed over her ear lobe.
The brunette closed her eyes immediately, cursing to herself. It wasn't that Shelby didn't turn her on; her girlfriend was a goddess and could turn her on with just a look. She was just scared of letting herself go. Whenever Shelby was touching her, it was natural for Toni to flip her over and either ride her fingers, her thigh or her face. "Shelb-..."
"Baby," she purred as she let her fingers tease along the bottom of the material. "I know what you've said, but just let yourself go. Just let me show you how good I can make you feel," she slipped her hand beneath the material and found the other girl's breast, teasingly dragging her thumb over her already hardened nipple.
"Shelby..." what sounded as if it was supposed to be a warning, definitely came out as more of a moan.
"I'll stop immediately if you tell me to, but just lose yourself in me," she kissed along her jawline, surprised by her girlfriend's lack of words. She would have thought Toni would shut her down at least five times by now. "Just let me touch you..." She kissed the corner of her mouth and watched Toni's eyelids flutter closed. A small noise escaped her lips as she rolled her nipple between her thumb and index finger. "...the way I want to."
Toni's mind was spinning, she struggled to collect her thoughts because of how clouded her mind was. A part of her wanted to just say fuck it and let Shelby do whatever she wanted with her, but she found it so hard to let it happen.
As the brunette reached down to grab a hold of Shelby's shoulder so she could flip them over like she usually did, her girlfriend had already grabbed a hold of both of her hands and pinned them above her head, moving quickly to straddle her thighs.
"I-"
Shelby didn't let her start her sentence, she crashed their lips together and immediately pushed her tongue into Toni's mouth. She was determined to prove how good she could make Toni feel. She was pleased with Toni's immediate response and ground her hips down into hers, letting out a small groan of her own as the brunette tugged on her bottom lip, her hips pushing up. It was obvious Toni was trying to regain some control by moving her hips firmly up against hers.
The blonde wasn't having any of it. She lifted her hips up and moved one of her thighs in between her legs instead, pressing up against Toni's core. She gasped at how wet she was, her body betraying her head. "God, you're so wet for me," she whispered against her lips, feeling Toni's hands trying to break free immediately. "I just want to fuck you so good," she pulled back a little to look directly into Toni's eyes.
Toni was taken aback by Shelby's dominance and felt her body respond in a way she hasn't felt before. She could feel her wetness covering Shelby's thigh. "Fuck," she groaned, her breath get caught in her throat as her eyes met Shelby's. "I just-"
"Be a good girl for me and let me touch you," the blonde cut her off, staring directly into brown eyes.
"Oh," Toni knew she was a goner at that point. She never knew Shelby's dominant side would turn her on this much nor did she think she would react how she did to being talked to like that. "Yes," she heard herself say, closing her eyes in what felt like embarrassment. Four relationships and no one had managed to get her like this, yet all it took was for Shelby to talk dirty and look at her like she did? Embarrassing.
The blonde forcefully hid how surprised she was and almost didn't know what to do, but instantly snapped back into her role as she removed her leg and once again pushed her hand underneath her sports bra, immediately rolling her nipple between her fingers again. Her actions spurred on with the way Toni's hips bucked, searching for friction as her eyes shut close. "Yes, what baby?"
"Shelby."
Shelby smirked as she decided to test the waters with the new power she was given. She wanted Toni to feel as good as she made her feel. She wanted her to feel everything she felt. She let her other hand wander down to lightly run down Toni's neck until her hand was firmly wrapped around her throat, brown eyes immediately snapping open to meet hers. "What do you want?"
Toni looked like she was about to flip them over in a second, Shelby had to bite down on her bottom lip in anticipation when she saw the brunette move her hand to meet hers, but she was pretty sure her lip was drawing blood when Toni's hand wrapped around her own, adding more pressure against her throat. "I want you. Touch me. Fuck me. I don't know... just... something before I change my mind. Please." she whimpered, feeling herself have zero control over her actions.
The brunette knew that if she thought too much about it then she would probably freak out and stop Shelby, but with her mind being too clouded, she felt powerless. The only thoughts she managed to form in her mind was that Shelby's hands felt so good on her body and the way she was acting was turning her on more than ever before.
"God..." Shelby gasped as she watched her girlfriend give herself up. "You're so good for me," she husked as she slid her hand down from her breast to between Toni's legs, both of them moaning at how wet she was. "Fuck."
"Shelby," Toni moaned as she spread her legs. "Please."
Shelby positioned herself between her legs and hovered above her, her fingers starting rubbing small circles on her clit. She was surprised with how quickly Toni was giving herself up, her hands immediately finding the blonde's shoulders and pulling her closer. "What? You want my fingers inside of you?" she teased, feeling Toni's hips buck hard at her words. She had no idea how much dirty talk turned her girlfriend on. Until now. "You want me to make you feel good?" Toni's breathing was out of control at this point, digging her nails into her girlfriend's shoulder as she nodded her head desperately.
Toni lifted her hips, trying to signalize what she wanted. She was growing frustrated with how painfully turned on she was and even more with how desperate she was being.
The blonde let go of her girlfriend's throat to steady herself on the mattress next to her head as her fingers sank inside of Toni, immediately building up a steady pace. There's no teasing, no needing to work Toni up and having her beg because Toni was already begging before she even started.
"Oh fuck." Toni gasped as her mouth fell open, holding on to Shelby's shoulders as her legs spread further apart to give her more room. "Harder."
Shelby complied, her fingers moving in and out of the brunette harder and faster. "You take my fingers so well baby," she praised, licking her lips as she felt Toni's walls clench around her fingers. "That's a good girl... Letting me fuck you so good."
The brunette let out a broken moan at Shelby's words, feeling like she could come simply from the way she was talking to her. "Fuck Shelby, fuck... Don't stop."
She fucked her with short, hard, quick strokes as her lips found Toni's neck, latching on to the skin there and altering between sucking and nipping. "Come for me," she demanded, feeling her walls once again clench around her fingers. "Show me how good I make you feel, baby."
Toni's mouth opened and her eyes slam shut, her walls clenched tightly around Shelby's fingers as she came hard. She's silent in her orgasm, but Shelby could feel the tension in her neck while she tried so hard to keep it together, holding on to the little power she still had left.
"Fuck, you're so sexy," the blonde whispered as she peppered kisses from her neck and all the way up to her lips, brushing their lips together. She kept her fingers deep inside of Toni until she came down from her high and smirked as a shaky breath escaped her girlfriend's lips the second she removed her fingers and before she knew it Toni had pulled her into a deep kiss.
Toni couldn't help herself with how good she was feeling, but she needed more. She needed more of Shelby. She moaned into her girlfriend's mouth, feeling her tongue entering her mouth as her legs wrapped around her hips to pull her flush against her body.
Shelby found the brunette so sexy like this as she started rocking into her, hitting Toni's clit directly and groaning as she felt the fingers tangle into her hair, tugging at it.
"Don't stop. Please, don't stop."
One of the blonde's hands reached past her and now pressed against the headboard for more leverage, the grinding doubled in pressure and speed.
Toni could hear herself growing louder at this point, but couldn't stop herself. Her moans were loud, raspy and whiny. She was positive she said something or at least tried to mumble how close she was already against Shelby's lips.
Shelby gave her one last kiss before pulling away from her lips, the hand that's not on the headboard grabbed onto her boobs as her lips moved to her neck, finding whatever skin she can find and biting down on it. "Come for me again," she encouraged her girlfriend, already feeling her breaking apart and grasping on to her, followed by her name being moaned loudly.
"Holy shit," Toni breathed out, her body still shaking with aftershocks. "I- Holy shit."
"Yeah?" Shelby giggled against her neck before pulling back, biting her lip at the sight of her girlfriend. "You look so fucking good when you come for me," she didn't say it with the intention of turning Toni on again, but she could see her eyes darkening and her hips twitching at her words. "Fuck," Shelby shook her head as she started smirking at her. "You want more, don't you?"
Toni bit down on her lip, her embarrassment being replaced with arousal and the need for Shelby to make her come again. "I-" her voice was shaky and she took a deep breath to at least try and calm herself down. "I want your mouth. Your tongue."
"So desperate for me," the blonde mused as she started kissing her way down her body, ignoring the way she could feel her own wetness dripping down her thighs.
"God," Toni whispered as she watched Shelby move between her legs, trying to lean a bit up on her elbows to watch her but fell down the second she felt her tongue on her. She felt her legs spread automatically, her stomach tensed and her legs twitching with how sensitive she already was.
Shelby moaned against her, humming in response. "You taste so good for me baby," she said with a glance up at her before her tongue was back on her clit, flicking over it and drawing circles in a way that Toni knew was going to make her come way too quick if she kept going like that.
"Fuck," Toni moaned, not being able to help the way her hips moved against Shelby's tongue, not being able to draw out how good it felt because she was already so fucking close with the way Shelby sucked her clit into her mouth before flicking over it with her tongue again. "Shelbs, I'm- fuck-"
The blonde is nodding against her, holding on to her thighs to keep her still as Toni once again was tipped over the edge. Her hips lifted off the bed as she came hard. Shelby stilled her tongue to let Toni grind and twitch against her, riding out her orgasm.
"I- I'm actually... I-" Toni is trying to form a sentence, but she felt absolutely ruined as Shelby's tongue retreated, but felt her whole body tense when she felt two fingers slip inside of her, filling her up and hitting a spot deep inside of her that made her let out the loudest moan yet. "Oh my God!"
"Tell me to stop if you can't take it." Shelby said. It sort of felt like a challenge and when Toni looked down at her, she licked her lips, letting out a quiet moan as she tasted her girlfriend on her lips.
That's all it took for Toni.
"Don't you dare stop," she shook her head, her hips already starting to move against Shelby's fingers. "Fuck me," she's gasping, her walls clenching and her hands grasped at whatever sheets, pillows or whatever the fuck that she could find next to her. She had never felt this desperation before and was fully prepared to let Shelby ruin her all night if she wanted to. "I need it."
"God, you're so wet for me," Shelby could feel her insides turn with the wet noises she's got from fucking Toni and it only spurred her on to fuck her deeper, curling her fingers inside of her. "All for me."
"Please," Toni pleaded, not even knowing what she was asking for, but Shelby seemed to understand anyway as she started fucking her faster. Before she knew it, she had tugged Shelby forward again, her palm rubbing against her clit with each thrust and she started shuddering. "I'm so fucking-"
"That's it, Toni. You're such a good slut for me."
Toni felt her orgasm hit her harder than ever before and wrapped both her legs and arms around her body as she let out a string of all kinds of moans. She had no idea where that word came from or how she would even react to it, but all she knew was that she had never felt herself come any harder than before hearing that and how badly she wanted to hear it again. Once she could feel her legs.
Shelby kissed Toni softly as she helped bring her back down and carefully slipped her fingers out before laying beside her girlfriend, needing to catch her own damn breath while she listened to Toni regain her senses. She watched proudly as her body was still shaking a little. "So..."
"Don't," the brunette rasped out, shaking her head as she lifted Shelby's arm and cuddled into her side. "Don't say a fucking word-"
"You liked it," Shelby confirmed, wrapping her arms around the shorter girl.
"Listen..." Toni chuckled, still not even knowing how to defend this. She had no idea that someone else could make her feel this good, that someone else would be able to map out all of her weak spots and make her feel this desperate to be touched. It wasn't embarrassing that Shelby made her feel good, but it was embarrassing how long she had denied her to do so. "Yes, you made me feel fucking good and I will probably let you do it again, but no need to..." she huffed as she felt Shelby shaking a little, trying to hold back a small laugh. "Make a deal out of it," she finished with a pout, hiding her face in her girlfriend's neck. "Don't make me regret agreeing to this."
Shelby raised an eyebrow as her right hand wandered down to smack Toni's ass, the brunette letting out a quiet yelp. "Don't make me remind you how good I made you feel Toni."
"Whatever," she wrapped her arm around her girlfriend's mid section and knew that she definitely needed to return the favor, but before she could give it another thought, she felt her eyes slowly starting to close shut as she drifted off.