Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of EIIDMS
Stats:
Published:
2022-11-05
Updated:
2026-02-24
Words:
280,653
Chapters:
36/40
Comments:
1,661
Kudos:
2,321
Bookmarks:
553
Hits:
78,424

even if it doesn't make sense

Summary:

Tim had given up trying to lie to himself about how he felt about Jason, hating himself for his childhood hero-worship/crush on the second Robin for coming back. He knew the whole thing was pointless – Jason barely tolerated him, he knew that – so it was better to just acknowledge the feelings, process them, and get rid of them. The last time he’d had feelings for Jason, suppressing them hadn’t worked despite years of trying.
So here he was, asking Jason about what consoles he had because unfortunately this was as close as Jason was going to come to asking him on a date (oh my god, a Bat Kids hangout was the closest he was getting to a date – Damian was right, Tim was pathetic), and there was no way in hell Tim was going to say no, even if he hadn’t slept in over 24 hours. Besides, he knew he could easily make it to 48 if he had coffee.

Notes:

Hi! As I mentioned in the tags, Ao3 somehow tricked me into shipping JayTim, so here we are. This is my first time posting a fic with multiple chapters, so we'll see how that goes lol. I've also never posted a fic with emojis in it, so please lmk if you can't see those for some reason and I'll try to fix it. Hope you enjoy!
Title from CWJBHN by Jake Scott and Josie Dunn
Feel free to follow me on Tumblr :)

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Sunday, October 9th, 2022

Jason scrubbed at his face and threw his phone down after erasing a message to the “BatKids” group chat for the fifth time. It bounced on the mattress and came back up to hit his knee. He snatched it back up and fell backward onto his pillow typing a single word to his group chat with the Outlaws.

 

OUTLAWS

Jaybird: Help

Royz: Are you dying?

Jaybird: No

Royz: Then suffer in silence

Art: 😂

Jaybird: I don’t know why I ever expect anything helpful from yall

Kori: Nooooo, we’ll help you Jay!

Biz: Biz am want to help Red Him

Royz: Whatcha need?

Jaybird: So remember how my therapist said I should reach out to people if I want to make amends?

Biz: Biz remember

Art: That was Kori but go ahead

Jaybird: Kori is my therapist she gets a check every month

Jaybird: How do I invite the Batbrats over to have a game night without sounding like a whiny bitch?

Kori: Awwww that’s so sweet Jason!

Kori: However I am wondering where this month’s check is

Art: 👀

Royz: Game Night. My place. If you don’t come you get shot.

Art: Yes do that

Art: Or

Art: A second option

Biz: Biz think Red Him Two idea bad

Art: UwU do my favwotiste people want to pway wedio games wif me?

Jaybird: I hate that you made me see that with my eyes

Royz: Please send that

Royz: I’m literally begging you to send that

Kori: “After patrol, I’m ordering a pizza and gaming for a few hours. If anyone is interested, I’ll just order a few extra pizzas. BYOC”

Kori: It’s very simple Jason

Jaybird: …

Biz: Star Her am kind and Biz love Star Her

Kori: Awwww, love you too Biz!! 💜

Royz: Damn

Royz: Someone stole my bitch

Art: Yeah

Art: Me

Jaybird: Thank you Kori

Art: *sends link*

Kori: Of course! 😀

Art: Dove Cameron was actually talking about ME AND KORI when she sang this song

Royz: 🖕

Kori: Ooh I’ve never heard this song!

Jaybird: You should listen to it, it’s good

Royz: Hey can somebody grab the knife Jay just stabbed me in the back with? I cant reach it

Art: 🙄

Biz: Biz worry for me friends brains

 

Jason flicked over to the BatKids group chat, a smile flickering across his face as he read the past messages again. Steph and Tim had been arguing over which Waffle House in Gotham had the most chaotic energy. He’d largely ignored it when it was happening so he’d felt weird about replying two hours later with “you’re both wrong, it’s obviously the one in Crime Alley” so he’d said nothing.

 

BATKIDS

Jason: Hey after patrol Im orderin pizza and gaming for a few hours. If yall want, I’ll order a few extra pizzas. BYOC

 

He threw his phone down and started changing into his Red Hood attire, not wanting to stare at his phone like Jane Bennet waiting at the window for Caroline Bingly to call on her while he waited for a response. He needed to get ready for patrol anyway.

He heard his phone vibrate against the sheets a few times but ignored it until he’d finished changing.

 

BATKIDS

Damian Wayne: Pizza is the food of the commoners, Todd. I will, however, be joining you regardless so I hope you prepare an adequate replacement meal for me.

DickieBird: He can get you a veggie pizza, they exist

Damian Wayne: I think you are missing the point, Grayson.

Timmers: What console do you have?

 

Jason blinked. He didn’t…he didn’t think Tim would say anything back, much less imply that he wanted to come over.

 

BATKIDS

Jason: Switch and PS4

Timmers: Sweet

Timmers: By BYOC I’m assuming you meant controllers and not consoles then?

Jason: Yeah

Timmers: Okay, I have two pro controllers and three joy-cons that I can bring. Steph do you have my ps4 controllers?

Duke: I have a couple for the ps4

Duke: Also I’m lactose intolerant sooooooo

Dickiebird: I think all of the pizzas at GothamSlice are lactose-free?

Jason: They’re also hella expensive

DickieBird: Okay, well, too bad

Jason: I’m not goin to fuckin Gotham slice.

DickieBird: You’re being rude.

Duke: It’s not that big of a deal, I can just take a lactate or something

DickieBird: It is a big deal!

 

Jason rolled his eyes and muttered a few choice words.

 

BATKIDS

Jason: I know that Dickface

Jason: I don’t buy from GothamSlice on fuckin principle

Jason: They overcharge on purpose because they’re in Bristol

Jason: Sal’s – the pizza place I was already planning on going to – has several options for dietary restrictions including lactose-free

Steph: @Timmers yeah you left them here after the Titans hangout last week

Jason: I’m not paying those assholes for an overpriced slice of garbage when Sals sells better pizzas for half the price 

Timmers: Cool, bring them with?

Steph: Sure

Steph : Also @Jason I prefer cheese pizza 😊

Jason: Aight blondie

Jason: @Duke I got you man, don’t worry abt it

DickieBird: Okay, sorry. 

 

Dick was clearly not sorry if he was using a period at the end of his sentence to indicate anger still. Jason rolled his eyes again, plastering on his domino. He didn’t really feel like wearing the helmet tonight so he left it in his apartment as he ducked out through the window.

 

BATKIDS

Duke: Thanks Jason

Cass: Gotham Slice 🍕 is the one that looks too 🧽🧼 isn’t it?

Steph: How can a restaurant look TOO clean?

Jason: Bc it’s in fuckin Bristol

 

Jason fired off his grappling hook and swung through the city, headed for the warehouse he was staking out that night. By the time he landed on the roof, he had twelve new messages from the group chat.

 

BATKIDS

Damian Wayne: Don’t be ridiculous, Cain.

Timmers: According to my parental units it was not clean enough actually

Timmers: So obviously the second they left for another trip after saying that I went in and ate as many pizzas as I could before throwing it all up in the parking lot

Timmers: Good times

Duke: 😭

Damian Wayne: You are disgusting, Drake.

Steph: I love that every single time you’ve tried to rebel it’s ended with you just hurting yourself 💜

Timmers: I love to cause myself pain 😌

Steph: Timmy you kinky bitch

Cass: 😂🤣😭

Damian Wayne: None of you know when to stop talking.

Babs: What games do you have Jay?

Jason: I don’t know

Jason: A lot?

Babs: How do you not know what games you have?

Jason: I don’t keep a fuckin catalog

Jason: If you ask me a specific game I’d know but I can’t just list them all off

Steph: Do you have animal crossing?

Steph: I bet he has animal crossing

Jason: I do have animal crossing actually

Jason: For your information Blondie, I have a four star island 😌😎

Babs: Good for you. Do you have any of the Call of Duty games?

Steph: Might bring my switch then. Visit your island

Jason: Obviously. I love killing people.

DickieBird: 🙄

Jason: I got black ops 3, advanced and infinite

Babs: Awesome

Jason : @Steph feel free

Timmers: We should do a Mario Kart tournament

Steph: LE GASP

Jason: I’m 90 percent sure I have Mario Kart somewhere in my apartment

Steph: TIMOLAS YOU KNOW YOURE NOT ALLOWED TO PLAY THAT ANYMORE

Timmers: I’ll bring mine just in case

Timmers: I don’t know what you’re talking about Stephabeth

Duke: I’m down for Mario Kart

Steph changed their name to Stephabeth

Stephabeth: Duke no

Stephabeth: You don’t know of what you speak

Timmers: You’re just still pissed I beat you

Stephabeth: THROUGH CHEATING

Jason: How the fuck do you cheat at Mario Kart?

 

Jason, unfortunately, couldn’t really wait for a response because the truck he’d been waiting for showed up. He stood from his crouched position and dropped down on them, knocking out the driver. Thankfully it didn’t take too long and he was able to reply to Dick’s last message before it got too late to say anything. He fired off his grapple gun, keeping his phone out as he made his way to the next stop on his patrol.

 

BATKIDS

Timmers: You cant she just sucks

Stephabeth: DON’T LISTEN HES EVIL

Timmers: Yes, I am so evil and bad and terrible

Timmers: They should lock me up

Timmers: The GCPD hates me

Timmers: I’ve committed the worst of crimes

Timmers: I use the shortcuts in Mario Kart 😔

Duke: Oh no guess I’m going to jail too

Babs: Can’t wait to see the disappointed look on my dad’s face when I turn myself in

DickieBird: Maybe we can all get like a joint cell together

DickieBird: When B comes to visit us he can smuggle in Mario Kart

Jason: Bold of you to assume B would visit you in prison after so egregious a crime

Stephabeth: I can’t believe there are so many hardened criminals in this chat

Stephabeth: Friendship with you all ended

Stephabeth: Jason is my new best friend now

Jason: no❤️‍🔥

Stephabeth: how dare you

Stephabeth: I come offering friendship and you have the nerve to reject it?

Jason: You have Cass

Cass: 🥰😇🥳

Stephabeth: No I know Cass, she will also choose the path of evil

Stephabeth: It’s preemptive

Cass: ☹️😢😤

Stephabeth: Also Cass is girlfriend, so different 

Babs: and how do you know Jason hasn’t also walked down this evil path with us Steph? 👀

Stephabeth: …

Stephabeth: he would have said something about not wanting to be in the same cell as yall

Jason: Or maybe I just don’t trust y’all enough to admit to my crimes 😇

Timmers: Fair enough, pls enjoy your freedom while you can

Jason: Thank you, I shall

Babs: Too bad Dick and I have already played Mario Kart with you

Jason: God fucking damn it

Jason: There goes my freedom

Timmers: So sorry for your loss

Damian Wayne: Stop conversing while we’re on patrol. Father keeps glaring every time my phone gets a notification.

Jason: Then silence it

Timmers: Just silence it

 

Jason huffed out a laugh as his and Tim’s texts came in at the same time saying the same thing.

 

Stephabeth: lol I was gonna say the same

Duke: same

Damian Wayne: It is silenced. I’m not an inept fool. The vibrations are still too loud.

Jason: You can mute the chat, Habibi. Click on the icon with three vertical buttons on the top right side and you’ll find the option

Damian Wayne: Thank you, Akhi, for being the only useful person in this chat.

 

Jason smiled at the endearment from his baby brother before exchanging his phone for his guns and shooting a drug dealer who’d been selling to kids in the face.

 

OUTLAWS

Jaybird: *sends attachments*

Jaybird: I’m so fucking good at un-estranging myself

Kori: Yay!

Kori: Proud of you! 😄

Royz: “I love killing people” fucking hell Jay 😂

Jaybird: I am nothing if not hilarious

Art: It’s two in the morning, shut up

Art: Congrats Jason. *Sent with confetti effect*

Jaybird: Thanks. *sent with echo effect*

Royz: Do you not do your crime fighting at night?

Art: No I usually work the day shift for my vigilante shit

Art: Perk of not being a Gotham or Star City BITCH

Royz: Rude

Jaybird: Rude

Jaybird: Also it’s only 12 here

Kori: Why are you not Jaybird in the chat with them? Is this not a nickname given to you by Dick?

Jaybird: It’s complicated

Royz: I actually take full credit for the creation of Jaybird as a nickname thank you very much

Art: what part of shut up escaped you people

Royz: Just mute the chat goddamn

Art: No

Art: This is a you problem

Royz: I’m glaring at you, I hope you know

Art: Don’t strain your eyes

Art: I might steal Kori away while you’re blinking

Art : @Kori 😘

Royz: shut up

Art: you first bitch

 

Jason swung around his city for a few more hours before dropping back into his apartment to change. He took out his phone.

 

BATKIDS

Jason: About to go order the pizza, besides the veggie for demon brat and the cheese for blondie I was going to grab three meat lovers and two supremes. They’ll all be lactose-free except for the cheese because Sal is weird about his cheese pizzas. Any other requests?

Babs: You haven’t ordered them yet?

Babs: Also, they’re all just getting back from patrol and changing in the Cave so they won’t be able to respond for a bit

Jason: Someone tell Alfred I said hi then

Jason: and no I was on patrol

Babs: I could’ve placed it online

Jason: no decent pizza place has the option to order online

Jason: That’s why Timbo puked up his guts after eating GothamSlice

Babs: hmmm yes, definitely has nothing to do with the fact that he ate 10 large pizzas

Jason: Jesus Christ

Jason: How did his tiny child body handle it

Jason: Well…guess it didn’t lol

Timmers: in my defense, I hadn’t eaten in two days so I was hungry

Timmers: and the pizza choices sound fine to me Jason :)

Cass: 2️⃣🥦🍕❓

Jason: Sure, I’ll grab two

Jason : Also…why the fuck did you not eat for two days? @Timmers

Timmers: Parentals were home and forgot to feed me but also they didn’t let me leave the house when they were there so 🤷🏻

 

Jason stared at his phone as he stopped in the middle of the staircase leading down to the street.

 

BATKIDS

Stephabeth: Tim we’ve talked abt trauma dumping

Timmers: not me forgetting that wasn’t a normal human experience for a second haha 😳

Timmers: sorry everyone

Duke: Tim how are you alive?

Timmers: In my defense, Jason did ask

Timmers: I am not sure

Timmers: Spite?

Stephabeth: Oh it’s definitely spite

Stephabeth: ALSO CASS, DAMIAN, AND DICK HURRY THE FUCK UP

Cass: Talking to Bruce

Jason: Tell Dick he’s in charge of buying drinks

Jason: I’ve just decided

Duke: Steph just leaned out of the car and screamed at Dick to let him know and now B is coming over

Jason: not to my apartment

Timmers: no to the car

Babs: The front seat better be empty when you get to my place Richard Grayson.

Duke: Tim just fucking DOVE into the middle seat from the passenger seat 😭

Duke: *sent attachment*

Duke: His foot got caught in the seat belt 😭

Babs: *loved an image*

Stephabeth: *laughed at an image*

Cass: *loved an image*

Damian Wayne: *laughed at an image*

Jason: *loved an image*

Timmers: *disliked an image*

Duke: Bruce is trying really hard not to laugh at him

DickieBird : @Jason Alfred says hello and hopes you’re doing well

 

Jason smiled as he entered the pizza place and pressed the love reaction on Dick’s text.

“Hi, welcome to Sal’s!” the girl at the counter – Kim – had taken his order a few times before so she beamed at him, “Your usual, Jace?”

He shook his head, “Nah, gotta couple more than usual tonight.” He rattled off the various pizzas and she punched them into the system.

“Party tonight?” she asked after sending the ticket to the back. Since it was so late, he was the only customer so he leaned against the counter on his elbows and grinned up at her.

“Something like that.”

She grinned back, popping her gum, “Sounds fun.”

Jason hummed noncommittally, “Hopefully.”

Kim tilted her head, “What’s up? You usually ask me what time I get off by now”

He laughed, straightening, “All right, Kim, what time you get off?”

“Seven. But you know that.” She said before he could ask his next question, twirling one of her curls around her finger. “You also know that I’m gonna go straight home and sleep for five hours before going to my next job and have absolutely no time to go on a date with you sweetheart.” She leaned forward, “No matter how much I might want to.”

He grinned at her slowly, “Kim, what are you saying?”

She poked his chest, her long nail sharp even through his shirt. “I’m saying I know this dance and if you miss a step it’s because your brain is thinking of things.”

Jason rolled his eyes, “My brain’s always thinking of things.”

She rolled her eyes right back, “Sure sweetheart. Tell me what it’s thinkin now then.”

He stared at her for a second, considered lying. “My…adopted siblings are coming over. I had a…pretty nasty falling out with them a few years ago, still trying to patch things up.”

Kim nodded, resting her chin on her hands as she propped her elbows up on the counter. “You close with them? Before I mean?”

Jason pressed his hip into the counter and sighed, “Only the two older than me. I hadn’t…I wasn’t around with the younger ones. I don’t even really see them as my siblings yet except for one of them – the youngest – and that’s only because we…were in a foster home together for a few years. But even with my older brother and sister, we weren’t that close. My…my brother tried but he was…going through his own thing. The falling out happened because I went through a very similar thing and just…handled it so much worse than he did.”

“But they’ve forgiven you?”

Jason shrugged, “I guess so.”

“Have you forgiven your older brother?”

“I…” Jason huffed a laugh and kicked the counter lightly, “I’m trying to. I need to. But it’s hard because he’s…constantly worried about the others, how badly I hurt them. He doesn’t even realize how he hurt me I think.”

“Have you talked to him about it?”

“We don’t really do emotions and talking well.”

“Try tonight, if you’re feeling up to it.”

He looked up at her, “Do you also have a secret third job as a counselor or something?”

Kim shrugged, “Sometimes I’m a substitute English teacher.”

He grinned, “Oh that counts. One of the city schools or Gotham Academy?”

She smiled back, “Gotham Middle. My favorite teacher was my sixth-grade English teacher so it just felt right.”

“Who’d you have?”

“Mrs. Baker. You?”

“Also her!” He grinned, “She was the best, wasn’t she? I was in drama with her too.”

She raised an eyebrow, “Wait, hang on. How old are you?”

“Twenty-three.”

“Huh. You would have been a freshman when I was a senior then.”

“Oh I didn’t go to Gotham High, I went to GA for high school.” Well, he would have if he hadn’t died.

She grinned, “Ooh, won the lottery?”

“Order up!”

As she turned to grab his pizzas he nodded, “Something like that yeah.”

She started stacking his boxes on the counter, “Did you want plates or anything sweetheart?”

He shook his head, “Nah, I got stuff at home. They’re all so fuckin bougie, probably don’t know how to eat off a paper plate,” he grinned.

She laughed, “Have a good night, Jace.”

“You too, Kim.”

Thankful that Sal’s is only a block away from his apartment, he started walking back. As he reached his block, he heard a car honk its horn behind him. He adjusted the pizza boxes so he could flip the driver off without looking back.

“Jason Peter Todd, you better not be flipping me off.”

Jason turned with a grin on his face to see Barbara in the passenger seat of the Subaru Dick had bought to lug all the Bat children around. She’d rolled the window down as Dick slowly drove down the street, keeping pace with Jason, “Oh never you, Barbara. It was aimed at Dickie, of course.”

She smiled back at him and inclined her head toward the pizzas, “Want a hand or two with that?”

Jason shrugged, “I guess.”

Dick stopped the car and the back door opened. Tim, Steph, and Duke – who had been sitting in the middle seat – tumbled out into the street. Steph and Duke took the boxes from him while Tim grabbed some bags filled with 2 liters and a couple of six packs from Cass in the backseat.

“Oh,” Jason said, seeing the beer, “I had alcohol, sorry. You drinking, Timmy?” He asked jokingly.

“Absolutely not,” Dick said quickly.

“I’m driving back so no,” Tim said, pulling the door closed. “Otherwise I would.”

“This is your reminder that I am a cop and you are underage,” Dick said with a frown.

Steph rolled her eyes, “Despite the soccer mom car, you’re not our dad, Dick.”

Jason managed to stop himself from laughing but Tim and Duke glanced over at him as if they were also holding back a laugh, making it harder than it should have been. Dick drove off to park and the four made their way up the stairs to his apartment.

“Personally,” Jason began, “I’m surprised you haven’t drank already, Tim. Figured Blondie would hook you up.”

Steph smirked at him, “Who’s to say I haven’t?”

Jason laughed, pulling his keys out of his pocket. He opened the door, “Just put the pizza on the counter. Are the drinks cold?”

“No,” Tim said.

Jason led Tim to the fridge. He grabbed two half-empty liters of Sprite and Dr Pepper that he was pretty sure were flat but hey, at least they were cold. He handed them to Tim, “Put those on the counter would ya?”

Tim nodded, leaving the six packs and two liters on the floor. Jason took out the beers he already had and stuffed the new ones in his empty crisper.

“Isn’t that where the vegetables are supposed to go?” Jason could hear the smirk in Tim’s voice as he stood behind him.

“Just shut up and hand me the soda, replacem –” Jason turned to look back at Tim, “I…Sorry.”

Tim shrugged but wouldn’t look him in the eye, “It’s fine.”

Fuck. He’d thought they’d been making progress to become friends and now he was fucking it up again . “Tim, I didn’t mean –”

“Just take the soda, Jason,” Tim said tiredly.

Jason swallowed and stood, opening the freezer and putting the drinks in there. Tim started to head for the couch where Steph and Duke were already sitting. Jason grabbed his arm to stop him. “I really didn’t mean to say that, Tim. I’m sorry.”

Tim glanced at Jason’s hand wrapping around just below his elbow before meeting his eyes, “I know. It’s genuinely okay.”

“It’s not okay,” Jason muttered, staring at his feet and refusing to let go of Tim just yet, “Every time…every time Dick looked at me like I had stolen something from him when he thought I wasn’t looking…fucking crushed me when I was Robin. I can’t…” he took a breath and looked up at Tim, “I know it’s got to be even worse for you because at least Dick didn’t actively try to kill me.”

“You’re not actively trying to kill me,” Tim smiled but to Jason, it looked forced.

“That’s literally not the point, Tim.”

Tim rolled his eyes, “Jason, it doesn’t –”

“Let us in!” Babs called, hitting on the door.

Tim rushed over to do so, yanking his arm from Jason’s grip. Jason picked up the beers, adding them to the counter.

Dick carried Babs into the living room on his back, her arms wrapped loosely around her shoulders. Cass followed behind with her wheelchair and Damian followed her with a red backpack in his arms.

“Jason, you should sue your landlord. That elevator clearly hasn’t passed inspection since at least the ‘50s.” Babs said as Dick lowered her to her wheelchair.

Jason leaned against his counter, “Oh yeah, sorry I forgot to mention. I forgot I even had one.”

“How do you forget an entire elevator, Todd?” Damian asked as Tim took the red backpack from him and moved towards the couch.

Jason shrugged as Steph held out her hands to Tim and made grabby motions, “Gimme, gimme, gimme I want to make fun of Jason’s island.”

Tim snorted, “Maybe look at it first so you can insult it properly.” He handed her a purple switch case and sat beside her on the floor.

Jason strode over to his entertainment center and unhooked his switch from the dock, “Friend code?”

Steph rattled it off and Jason added her as a friend.

“Wait, what’s yours, Jason?” Duke asked, looking up from his own switch.

Jason blinked but looked back down at his switch and told him. Immediately he had four new friend requests. He looked up to see Babs, Tim, and Damian looking at him expectantly. He quickly accepted their requests.

“Jesus, how the hell have you racked up over 100 hours in Unpacking?” Steph asked, looking up.

Jason shrugged, “I dunno. Helps me relax.”

“Jaybird.”

Jason tried not to flinch at the nickname and turned to Dick, “Yeah?”

“Say your friend code again?” Dick asked, pulling his switch out. Cass, who’d just taken hers from the bag, nodded, indicating she wanted it too.

Jason rattled it off again before handing his switch to Babs, “Let them on my island while I go downstairs for ice?”

“Course.”

“Don’t let them steal anything!” Jason warned, running out the door.