Work Text:
More Than He Bargained For
Casey and Derek were attending Queens University together as freshman something they were both apprehensive about, for all their claims of dislike and hatred toward each other having someone you know close by made the transition from home to being on your own much easier. Something neither one of them wanted to admit out loud.
Nevertheless, they had sat down at Casey’s request to discuss rules and guidelines for their time at Queens. There had been some rules about no pranks and respecting each others time and space, Derek retorting that he wouldn’t be slumming it with nerds in university, so she had no worries.
Though they both knew that as soon as school started Derek would be running to Casey for help with his assignments and she would begrudgingly help him out because she couldn’t just let him fail. Derek was assured of this because he had swiped a copy of Caseys schedule and decided to accidentally take some of the same elective classes so he could abuse the keeners time and notes, already violating rules, how very Derek of him. Plus, no matter how much Casey bitched at him they were there for each other when it counted.
Moving-in had gone as well as it could have, the McDonalds moved in Casey and the Venturi’s moved in Derek. Made easier by the fact that the housing office not decided to put them both in the same dorm and on the same floor. Oh, how the universe mocked Casey. Though their rooms were pretty close Casey had a private room, courtesy of her guilt-ridden absentee father. Casey was in a single room within a pod of girls giving her people close by to bond with but ultimately her own space. Derek on the other hand shared a room with another hockey player and a washroom with every guy on the floor.
After FROSH week was over, they settled into a routine with their new friends, Derek and his roommate Reese became gym rats when they weren’t at practice, being freshman didn’t really provide them with the popularity of some of the more seasoned players on the team. Casey on the other hand made friends with her pod mates Amanda an English major and Jessica who as of last week became a fellow member of the Queens dance team. They all bonded based on proximity and floor/team spirit in their FROSH week activities and became quite the little group. With Casey and Derek sharing so many classes together they and their friends tended to spend all their time together studying and or eating together as their schedules allowed.
They had a good group of friends and had actually become part of each others’ circles. And as far as anyone at Queens knew they were friends from high school and nothing more, both had agreed that they needed a fresh start here without being linked to each other but as always with Casey and Derek they always end up in each others orbits.
On to the actual story…
Practice hadn’t been challenging enough today, and he had only had one class before that, so Derek was relatively bored, returning from practice he threw himself in his bed hoping to find something to do to relieve this boredom that didn’t involve schoolwork or going to the gym. He came to the realization that this would be an opportune time to prank Casey, they had been on such good terms lately that she would have her guard down just enough for a little prank. And he had made that copy of her key just after she moved-in, just in case he needed it.
He didn’t have much in the way of money to go crazy plus he wasn’t really in the mode to get reprimanded or suspended, but he could take something from her, just something big enough she’d notice but not big enough that she would freak out and get someone with authority involved. He thought about it and decided that he could probably take the thing she valued most, her planner. That would definitely set her off and she would definitely know it was him that did it because who else would steal a person’s planner. She had given him a copy of her schedule so that they could coordinate study time so he knew she was currently at dance practice and would more than likely have left the planner in her room.
He sauntered down the hallway to Casey’s POD hoping there wouldn’t be any witnesses so he wouldn’t need to come up with an excuse for his presence. Lucky for him all the doors inside the pod were closed so he went right up to her room unlocked the door and let himself in. He took in his surroundings he hadn’t been in her room alone before and definitely had never taken the time to look around. It was just as neat as back home but gone was the pink princess vibe and in came the collegiate college student vibe everything was grey and gold and there were posters on the wall and a large whiteboard organized into tiny boxes with tasks a la Casey. With her room being so neat and only being so big it was easy for him to search for the planner. Which he unfortunately didn’t find, damn Casey probably brought it with her everywhere to make sure she was always on schedule.
With this realization he threw himself on the bed to think of something else to steal but he landed on something hard. He got up and moved back the covers finding a curved thing, he wasn’t sure exactly what it was, but it resembled a face brush that he’d seen Kendra use once when he was over at her house, she never shut up about how expensive it was, based on that he figured it would be important to Casey and not easy to replace. Perfect he though, this would be something small enough to piss her off but be significant enough that she would notice it was gone, he pulled the covers back up so she wouldn’t immediately notice the missing item and then looked around the room making sure his presence wasn’t visible. He put the thing in his pocket and then he slipped out locking the door behind him. Knowing Casey would be back soon and would be looking for it, he walked out of the pod and went back to his room. When he reached his room, he tossed it on the bed with his sweater and went to do an assignment for his Historically Significant Films tutorial that was due the next day.
Reese came in a few minutes later and was taking off his jacket and backpack when looked over at Derek’s bed and saw what was on it.
“Um D, what the hell is on your bed dude?” Reese asked concerned.
“What do you mean?” Derek said looking over at the bed “Oh that, I think its one of those face things girls use, I stole it from Case to piss her off.” Derek retorted.
“Dude that is most definitely not a facial cleaning brush, first of all there isn’t even a brush part.” Reese smirked.
“Maybe she keeps it separate.” Derek said ignoring his friend’s smirk “What is it, if its not that face wash thing?” Derek questioned. “It looks pretty expensive either way so Case will definitely notice its missing and be looking for it, and I’ll make her beg to get it back.
“No worries there she’ll definitely be begging you to return it.” Reese said pointedly.
“Ok, share with the class anytime bro.” Derek said crossing his arms and picking up the offending item. He turned it on, and it began making a sucking noise that Derek found odd.
“Dude, seriously, it’s a sex toy.” Resse said matter-of-factly. Derek dropped the thing and it fell onto his bed just moving around from the motor vibrations.
“What, no dude, your wrong, why would she even own that.” Derek said “Wait, how do you know that?”
Reese just giggled at Derek’s reaction. “So, it definitely is a sex toy and turn it off, its not going to stop other wise.” Reese said, Derek did as he was told touching it like it was diseased.
“You’re sure that is a sex toy, how would you even use it.” Derek asked looking over at it.
“I’m sure because, I bought one for Ange while were apart, or well Ange picked it out and I paid for it. It simulates oral sex; we use it for phone sex, and Ange uses it alone too.” Reese said about his girlfriend who went to university in Ottawa.
“Dude, you seriously bought your girlfriend a sex toy, I thought those were like for perv’s.” Derek said.
“Seriously man, there is an entire world of pleasure out there you are missing. Not that I’ve used one myself, but Ange swears by this thing and her O face always gets me so it’s a win-win.” Reese said.
“TMI man, didn’t need to know about your sex life, or Casey’s for that matter. I can probably return it before she gets back, and we can act like this never happened.” Derek said not wanting to deal with this anymore.
“Whatever man just leave me out of your little fourplay or whatever this is. Cause Casey is definitely going to freak.” Reese said throwing his hands up in defeat.
“Thanks for the help.” Derek said. He grabbed the thing by the bottom holding it away from him and went back to Casey’s room.
Again, he looked around to make sure there wasn’t any nosey neighbors lurking around. And went into her room. He planned to throw it on the bed hoping to get out of there as quickly as possible without having to think about Casey on said bed using that thing which was giving him a boner and a complex because he thought he was finally getting over his thing for Casey. Throwing it on the bed it hit her laptop which was tucked partially under her pillow, so he hadn’t seen it before, and the screen lit up with the last thing on the screen.
Derek didn’t mean to snoop really, but as he was leaving but the video started playing and he noticed the title. It seemed that Casey not only had a sex toy, but she watched porn to, and she was currently watching a pretty raunchy one that Derek had seen before.
It was about stepsiblings who have sex behind their oblivious parents back and by the looks of the tabs open the other videos she chose had a similar theme. Maybe, the princess had a bit of a naughty side, which may work out for the both of them if her browser history was any indication. He looked at the clock and came up with a plan.
He had about 15 minutes before she came back from dance practice, he left the room a mess so she would know who to blame and then left the video paused at his favourite part and took her toy back to his room to wait for her inevitable freak out and the scene that he knew would enfold.
When he returned with the toy Reese was confused. “I thought you were returning that?”
“Decided to play with Case instead, she likes toys and I like games so this should be interesting.” Derek said with a wink.
“I don’t even want to know what your planning, I’m just going to take my econ textbook and go to the library to study. Text me when I can come back.” Reese said grabbing his stuff and leaving.
“Probably a good call.” Derek said sitting back on his bed and thinking about his next move. If he wanted this to work out for both, he had to get her without scaring her.
He sat at his desk and came up with a plan. And sure enough 20 minutes later he heard an angry scream coming from a far, then someone running down the hall and finally Casey screaming “Der-ek” and banging on his door. He was waiting and opened it as soon as she knocked causing her to fall into him when he opened the door.
“Hey Case, what’s up?” Derek asked.
“You know what’s up, you trashed my room” she screamed, moving into the room.
Derek closed the door behind her and said, “Your room is trashed Princess, who could have done that. I’ve just been here all afternoon completing my assignment.” Feigning sincerity.
“You know damn well it was trashed because it was you who did it.” Casey fumed.
“Why, Casey how can you accuse me your Stepbrother” Derek said. Emphasising the relationship, they didn’t dare talk about in their new lives.
Casey was confused and became a little flustered at the statement but barked out angrily. “Because I know you, and I am pretty sure you got a copy of my key somehow, and you are the only person who would do something like this.” Casey said staring at him and when he smirked, she looked away and right at his bed which held her toy. She turned crimson from what Derek could see of her skin it was from head to toe as soon as she laid eyes on it. But didn’t say anything or make a move to grab it.
Derek followed her line of sight, honestly this couldn’t have worked out better if he planned it. “Oh yeah, I guess I did trash your room. I stole whatever this is too. Looks like some torture device women use. Makes a crazy noise too.” Derek said turning it on and looking it over.
“Never mind, I’ll clean up my room just give it back and we can call it a day.” Casey said trying to calm herself and get the toy back without Derek figuring out what it was.
“Awe Case you gonna forgive your Stepbrother for his transgressions. That is so big of you.” Derek said moving closer to Casey to return the item.
“Sure, whatever just give it to me, and we can move on, its just a room and I had to clean it anyway.” Casey said clearly confused by Dereks constant mention of their relationship had he changed his mind and told people how they really knew each other.
He put the item in her hand but grabbed her wrist and said, “By the way case you should really put a password on your laptop.”
Casey swallowed hard because she then remembered why her toy was in her bed and what she had been doing earlier that afternoon to blow off steam after class. She tried to pull away and get out of there because Derek was just going to continue to make fun of her and she wasn’t really interested in being made fun of right now.
He used his new hockey muscles to pull her in close to him and whispered in her ear “if you needed help with releasing some frustration you could have come to me, I can guarantee you the real thing will blow your mind and that toy away.” Derek said.
Casey blushed hard; he was joking he had to be. No way did Derek the bane of her existence also harbor some feelings for her. Derek didn’t do feelings; this was about catching her. She refused to dignify him with a response and tried to pull away again, because if he was serious then this was probably just about sex, so she owned a sex toy, didn’t mean she wanted a hook-up she was still Casey and she still only did relationships and commitment.
Derek didn’t let her get away and instead pulled her tighter so her back was flush against his front, and she could feel his erection pressed against her backside. It was not at all what she had expected, yes she was a version in the classical sense but she had done other things with her boyfriends and she had seen and felt a penis before and to her surprise what she was feeling against her backside right now was significantly bigger than anything she had seen or felt previously, which was causing a pool to form between her thighs. She was starting to crave friction for relief, and she knew that soon her horny brain would take over for her rational brain if she didn’t get out of this situation. She made one final feeble attempt to free herself, letting Derek envelop her with both arms, then decided that two could play at this game and wiggled around until she was turned, and they were chest to chest. She looked up at him at that moment willing to see something in his eyes that would make sense of all of this, was it real or was this still part of the prank.
He looked down at her and was mesmerized by the blues of her eyes, he’d never had her so close for so long. He wanted to kiss her, touch her, and know how she tasted.
Derek decided to stop being such a puss, they were away from home, alone and if their current predicament was any indication, it was time for him to make a move. He bent his head down and brushed his lips against hers ever so lightly, she closed her eyes, and he took it as a sign to try again with a little more contact. She kept her eyes closed and kissed him back. She slid her arms up to his neck and began playing with the curls at the nape of his neck and his necklace.
He could barely focus because he was finally kissing Casey after 3 years of silently pining over a girl he couldn’t and shouldn’t have. He started moving them back toward the bed and Casey jumped up and wrapped her legs around him trying to get more friction. And holy hell was Casey grinding on him, he was about to lose it. He could have made it to the bed and set them down together, but he wouldn’t be Derek if he didn’t throw Casey down on the bed and then flop on top of her.
“Der-ek” she said angrily glaring at him for tossing her on the bed.
He just smirked and said, “Sorry princess, let me kiss it all better.” With that he climbed on top of her and started kissing her lips then he moved down to her ear nipping at her lobe, then he bit his way from her ear to her clavicle, leaving as many marks as he could. He needed to leave proof that this had actually happened so he would know he wasn’t dreaming. He continued kissing down to her chest, she was wearing only a sports bra since she had just come from dance.
“Lift your arms princess.” Derek commanded, with a softness and he looked into her eyes asking for permission to continue, she blushed and nodded lifting her arms. He helped her free herself of the offending garment, once it was off she immediately brought her arms up to cover herself.
“Princess…” He whispered in her ear. “What was the point of taking your bra off if you were just going to cover those perfect tits.” He bit her ear and she moaned.
But she wouldn’t be Casey if she didn’t give a little fight back. “I’ll uncover my chest when I’m not the only one who’s got their top off.” She smirked.
She didn’t have to say that twice Derek’s shirt was off and across the room within seconds, Casey giggled at his swiftness and uncovered her breasts. Derek just stared at them in awe, they really were perfect. He shook his head as if to stop his zoning out and went back to making out with Casey, he was going to go straight to pleasuring her boobs, but he could tell she needed a little coaxing. So, he continued to kiss her and slowly started to play with them by massaging them. Once she started moaning, he started his kissing down from her mouth and landing on her breasts. He took one in his mouth and Casey let out the loudest moan he heard from a girl, he took a minute to imagine what she would actually sound like if they were having sex and decided that Casey was definitely not going to be the quiet kind. He sucked one her left breast and played with the nipple on her right and then switched. At this point Casey was soo turned that her pussy felt like it was leaking she was sure that there would be a stain on Dereks comforter, but she really didn’t care because this was heaven.
Derek started to move his hands down from her right breast to the waist band of her dance shorts and Casey squirmed. Derek wanted to take that as a go ahead but instead he stopped everything and sat up.
Casey looked at him in disbelief did he just stop in the middle of this, “Der-ek. Why did you stop?” Casey said her lips were puffed from kissing and her hair was mussed. Derek thought she looked absolutely gorgeous, but he knew they needed to talk before they went any further because they were approaching a point, he wasn’t sure she was ready to cross.
“Casey, owning a sex toy and wanting to have sex is one thing but actually doing it is another. I don’t want you to wake up tomorrow and regret not waiting.” Derek said and then whispered, “or regret sleeping with me.” Looking away, he couldn’t take.
Casey just looked at him like he was stupid, she reached out and grabbed his hand which just made Derek look down at their intertwined hands. Casey grabbed his face, so he was now looking at her, “Derek, no offense but are you stupid.” Derek just looked at her with a pained expression.
“I’m in love with you Derek, have been for a long time, not that I was willing to admit that to anyone until recently. I mean how could I not be you are an amazing guy who is always there for me when I need you and you’re not to bad to look at either.” She said. “I was willing to go all the way with you because I figured this was the only way I could have you, which is still fine with me. I mean its not …” Casey was cut-off with Dereks lips on hers.
“Princess, I love you too.” Derek said when he pulled away. They were both smiling from ear-to-ear.
Derek climbed up to the top of his bed where the pillows were and pulled her into his lap, they sat like that for a bit just touching each other and talking about anything and everything. They agreed to try out being in a relationship and seeing where it goes but they both knew that they were in it for the long haul.
They were sitting together Casey’s back pressed up against Dereks just enjoying being together, when she noticed the wet spot from earlier, remembering the conversation from earlier she said, “You know, I think there was mention of you blowing my mind and my toy away.” Casey said turning so she could look at Derek.
At the mere mention of pleasuring Casey, Dereks eyes became hooded, and his pupils were blown with lust. “Well princess, I always keep my word. So, lets get that mind blown.” He said crawling around her and kissing her hard. He had her moaning in seconds and then he made is way down her body determined to show Casey just how much better he was than her stupid, now forgotten toy.