Work Text:
He’d won the Pittfest tickets during a chaotic hospital holiday party—the kind where the fluorescent lights buzzed louder than the busted speaker in the corner, paper snowflakes drooped from ceiling tiles, and nurses downed spiked punch from Styrofoam cups like it was the last thing holding their sanity together. He didn’t remember entering any raffle. Someone had shoved an envelope into his hand and yelled over the noise, “Guess you’re going to Pittsburgh!”
It made no sense. Pittsburgh was six hours away by car—longer if you counted the flight delays, TSA lines, and December cancellations. No one at County took real vacations. Not during the holidays. Not ever. But for once, maybe out of sheer exhaustion or temporary insanity, Peter Benton booked the flight.
Reese had left for med school, and since then, their time together had been reduced to grainy FaceTime calls and rushed holiday visits. The trip felt overdue. Peter kept wondering how much the boy had changed—how much of the kid he raised was still under that white coat.
He would regret taking those tickets for the rest of his life.
Pittfest delivered exactly what it promised—too loud, too crowded, vibrating with bass and drenched in the mingled scent of grilled meat, sugar grease, and sweat. People packed the streets shoulder to shoulder. Vendors yelled over each other. Music pounded from every direction.
Reese stood beside him, grinning, a plastic cup of beer in hand.
Peter still couldn’t get over that part—his kid, drinking legally. He’d been of age for years now, but some part of Peter hadn’t caught up.
And for a moment—just one brief, golden moment—Peter exhaled. Let the tension go. Let himself feel the simple, rare joy of being with his son, surrounded by noise and light and life.
Then the shots rang out.
Sharp, staccato cracks—firecrackers, he thought at first. But no one screamed over fireworks. And no one ran like that unless it was real.
The music faltered, the crowd became aware, and then everyone scattered. Screams tore through the laughter of those who hadn’t yet realized what was happening. He could only watch in shock, as bodies dropped like dominos.
His brain kicked into instinct before fear had a chance to form.
He didn’t remember deciding—only the feel of Reese’s jacket in his hand, the force of yanking him backward, the two of them hitting the pavement behind a parked car hard enough to rattle his teeth. The sharp tang of exhaust and hot asphalt filled his nostrils. Reese’s breath came in short, staccato bursts beside him, his fingers clenched tight in Peter’s coat.
Then came the glass.
A window exploded behind them in a cascade of sound—high, splintering, glittering. It showered over their heads in sharp little stars. Something hot slammed into Peter’s shoulder. A burst of white, blinding pain—like being branded from the inside.
He didn’t scream. There wasn’t time. His body froze, but his brain didn’t. He had to protect Reese. That was all that mattered.
Peter clamped a trembling hand over the bullet wound, hot blood seeping through the shredded fabric of his coat, slicking his fingers, dripping down his ribs in warm, insistent rivulets. Glass bit into his knees as he shifted position, forcing his body to shield Reese more completely from the gunfire tearing through the air. The acrid stench of gunpowder mingled with the coppery tang of blood, thick in his nostrils, suffocating.
Reese stared up at him, face drained of color, eyes glassy and too wide. His mouth moved before sound came.
“Dad?” His voice was thin. Frightened. “You’ve been shot.”
Peter nodded once, a tight jerk of his head. His throat felt like sandpaper, his voice raw and useless. Of course he’d been shot. The fire in his side told him that much. But the pain didn’t matter. Not now. Not with Reese here. Not with bullets still raining like metal hail around them. Staying alive wasn’t the priority—keeping Reese alive was.
Gunfire cracked and echoed across the festival grounds for what felt like hours, though it couldn’t have been more than ten minutes. At some point, two kids—just teenagers—crawled toward them, ducking low, faces streaked with blood and dust. The boy couldn’t have been older than sixteen, clutching his leg where a bullet had torn through the muscle. The girl beside him gasped for air, a dark bloom spreading across the front of her shirt—chest wound. Bad.
Peter acted on instinct. He yanked off his belt and wrapped it tight around the boy’s thigh, turning it into a makeshift tourniquet. The boy whimpered, biting his lip, but didn’t cry out.
“Are you a doctor?” the boy asked, voice shaking.
Peter pressed his jacket against the girl’s wound, trying to stanch the bleeding. His hands were soaked in red. “Yeah,” he said, not looking up. “I’m Peter.”
“Jake,” the boy replied, struggling to keep his voice steady. “Man, Are we lucky to have found you.”
Peter met his eyes for a second. “We’ll get out of here,” he said. “It’s going to be alright. I promise.”
But even as he said the words, he knew he was lying. The girl was fading too fast—shallow breaths, fluttering eyelids, too much blood already lost. Help wasn’t coming fast enough.
And there was nothing he could do but keep lying to a child while another bled out in his arms.
They were found maybe ten minutes later by an EMT sprinting through the wreckage. No gurneys, no stretcher teams. Just gloved hands hauling Peter, Jake, and the girl into the back of a truck, its red-streaked doors yawning open under the spinning wash of lights. Reese climbed in after him, his small hand clamped around Peter’s like a lifeline. That grip kept him conscious. That grip was everything.
The hospital doors burst open, not like sanctuary—like the gates of hell. A nurse directed Reese to the waiting room, but he could tell his son didn’t want to leave him. He nodded at him to leave and let the Doctors do their job. Begrudgingly, he left, and Peter prayed it wasn’t the last time he’d ever see his son.
The second the wheels slammed into the tile, Peter felt it—the chaos.
The air crackled with adrenaline. Shouts bounced off the walls, urgent and overlapping—doctors barking orders, nurses calling for vitals, someone screaming for more O-neg. The stench hit him like a wall: blood, sweat, antiseptic, panic. Patients spilled across every surface—gurneys, floor mats, bare tile. Anywhere there was space.
A nurse knelt beside a teenager, hand-bagging him while another shoved an intubation tube between his teeth. An IV bag swung from a coat rack. A man lay open in the hallway, his abdomen split wide, viscera steaming in the fluorescent light while two residents worked elbow-deep, shouting over each other for suction.
Someone cried out—a child. No one moved. No one had the hands to spare.
This wasn’t a hospital. This was a battlefield.
“Trauma Five?” a nurse shouted over the chaos.
“Full!” another voice shot back.
“Hallway Three!”
His gurney whipped around a corner, the jolt sending a white-hot spike of pain through his shoulder. He clenched his jaw so tight it ached, forcing the scream back down his throat. Not now. Not yet.
A young woman—barely more than a girl—jumped onto the edge of the stretcher, one knee braced by his ribs, both hands pressing into the soaked cloth of his coat.
“You’re alright,” she panted, voice high and taut with effort. “I’ve got you. Just stay with me, sir—pressure’s holding.”
Her hands were trembling.
Another face joined hers. He was much older, with salt and pepper hair, blood smeared across his jaw like war paint. “Name? Do you know where you are?”
Peter’s mouth moved before his thoughts caught up. “Peter Benton,” he rasped. “Hospital... somewhere that’s bleeding out of chest tubes.”
The young man cracked a humorless smile and slid an oxygen mask over his face. “We’ll take care of that shoulder. Straight to OR as soon as a table opens.”
“No tables open,” someone muttered. “Overflow. Prep it now.”
Overflow meant the middle of the ER center, surrounded by dozens of others who had been shot. Out of the corner of his eye, he saw someone bring in Jake and the girl, he just hoped they would make it.
“You’re doing great, Mr. Benton,” the girl said, adjusting her grip. Blood still oozed between her fingers.
“It’s Dr. Benton,” he corrected faintly, eyes fluttering. “I used to run trauma— County General.”
She blinked. “Chicago? Seriously?”
“No shit,” the older doctor said. “Sorry, you're in an ER on your day off.”
He gave a weak, crooked smile. “She’s doing better than half my interns. You’ve got a good team here.”
The older doctor laughed. “It’s her first day.” Her shoulders lifted—maybe pride, maybe fear. It didn’t matter.
More hands. Another IV. Ice-cold saline snaked up his arm. He didn’t flinch. Couldn’t. The pain in his shoulder throbbed in time with his pulse. Crushed muscle. Possibly chipped bone. If the brachial artery was hit…
Focus.
He gripped the girl’s wrist. “Don’t let me crash.”
“You’re not crashing,” she said, firmer this time. “You’re staying awake.”
“I’ll haunt you if I code,” he mumbled.
She almost laughed. “Noted, Dr. Benton.”
Then came a shift in the room. Not louder. Quieter. Focused.
The attending stormed in.
Peter didn’t have to look—he felt it—like a pressure drop before lightning hits. Authority charged the air, sharp and immediate, pressing down on every breath.
Then the man stepped into view.
Tall. Lean. The kind of strength that came from dragging bodies out of wrecks and pounding on shattered chests through twenty years of 2 a.m. codes. His gown clung to him, soaked with sweat. His eyes, bloodshot and rimmed with fatigue, still cut like glass—precise, unflinching, alert.
Then Peter saw his face.
Everything inside him froze.
That jaw. That voice barking orders. That presence that turned chaos into control.
John Carter.
Jesus Christ.
Peter hadn’t seen him in over a decade—not since that bleak, gray morning outside the rehab center off I-55. The one where Carter sat silent in the passenger seat, fists clenched, eyes fixed ahead like he was already gone. Peter had walked him to the door, then waited in the car, engine running, hands locked on the steering wheel. Just waiting—for a word, a look, anything.
Carter never came back out.
He never came back to County, either.
Peter had searched for years. Dug through hospital databases, made calls, asked around. Nothing. Not even his family knew where he’d gone. Eventually, Peter stopped looking—not because he stopped caring, but because he was scared of what he might find. A name in a coroner’s file. A story whispered in past tense. No one just disappears unless they want to be dead.
But now—here he was.
Running the ER in the middle of a war zone.
Bodies poured in through every door. Blood soaked stretchers. Screams cut through the static of overlapping voices. Gurneys jammed the hallways, IV poles clipped to anything that would hold them. Surgeons operated under fluorescent lights, elbow-deep in open wounds without time for drapes or gloves that fit.
“Two units O-neg, stat!”
“He’s crashing—no pulse!”
“Get me that thoracotomy tray, now!”
Peter squinted against the lights as the gurney jolted past another row of stretchers. A teenager gasped for air around an intubation tube. A nurse crouched beside a little girl, trying to stop the bleeding from a shredded hand. The walls looked painted in blood—red handprints smeared across tile and stainless steel.
And in the middle of it all stood Carter—-sleeves rolled, mask around his neck, scrubs soaked with someone else’s blood. Commanding the room with the clipped urgency of someone who didn’t have time to second-guess a single thing.
The man looked so different from the young man he used to know. But it was Carter. Older, harder. Peter’s breath caught, the pain in his shoulder forgotten. This wasn’t just trauma. This was resurrection.
He saw the flash of surprise when he saw him, but it was quickly masked. He moved toward Peter without hesitation, instantly getting to work.
“Vitals?” Carter asked the older doctor
“BP 82/56. Through-and-through to the left shoulder. Still bleeding,” he answered. “We’ve got this Robby. Go check on Jake.”
“Jake’s fine,” he said. “Bullet hit his leg, but someone was smart enough to get a tourniquet on him to stop the bleeding.”
“I’m sorry about Leah,” the older doctor said.
Peter’s heart kicked against his ribs. Jake. Leah. The kids from Pittfest. How the hell did Carter know them?
“Jack, 14 blade, pressure pack, flush,” Carter ordered, already peeling back the blood-soaked gauze from Peter’s shoulder.
Peter stared up at him, dizzy, lips cracked. “Carter,” he croaked.
The other doctor—Jack—glanced up, brows knitting. “Carter?”
Carter didn’t even look up. “My name is Dr. Robinavitch,” he said. “You’re confused. You’ve lost a lot of blood.”
Peter pushed against the gurney, trying to sit. Agony lanced through his spine like a live wire. “Don’t bullshit me,” he hissed. “I trained you. I know your voice. You can grow a beard but I still recognize you.”
Still nothing. Carter worked methodically, hands steady, face unreadable. He packed gauze like he was patching drywall.
“We’ll irrigate and pack. If the artery’s clipped, you’ll need vascular. Hold still.”
“You disappeared,” Peter growled. “Rehab. Then nothing. We thought you were dead.”
Carter finally looked at him—just a sliver of a glance. “Clearly, I’m not.”
Peter gave a breathless, pained chuckle. “That’s it? No explanation? No ‘hey, sorry for vanishing off the face of the earth’?”
The scalpel paused. For a beat, Carter didn’t speak. Then he looked down—really looked. And Peter saw it. The flicker behind the eyes. The ghost hiding in the man’s skin. He saw the intern who fumbled his first central line, the surgeon who lost Lucy, the friend who walked into rehab and never came out.
“Your only job right now,” Carter said, voice low, steady, “is to stay alive.”
Peter narrowed his eyes. “That’s your big comeback? After all these years?”
Silence fell sharp as a cracked rib. The background noise seemed to stretch—screams, metal trays clattering, the faint, electric whine of the overhead lights.
Jack looked between them, clearly out of his depth, but smart enough to stay quiet.
Carter’s jaw tensed. “You were the only one who didn’t give up on me,” he said. Barely audible. Like it hurt to say out loud. “Don’t start now.”
Peter froze.
And then Carter pressed a gloved hand to his chest—firm, grounding, surgical.
“Welcome to the Pitt, Dr. Benton,” he murmured.
It was already the worst day of his life.
And that was before he saw Peter Benton bleeding out on a gurney in the middle of his trauma bay.
Dr. Michael Robinavitch—Carter—didn’t freeze. He didn’t allow himself that luxury. His hands kept moving, his voice stayed sharp, barking out orders above the chaos. But inside, something cracked open. Something he’d sealed shut years ago.
County General came flooding back before he could stop it.
He’d spent years trying to forget that place—really forget it. But County had a way of clinging to him like the smell of antiseptic on old scrubs. A flash of skyline, a patient’s cadence, someone mentioning Chicago in passing, and suddenly he was back in his early days—shadowing Dr. Benton like a second shadow, heart pounding, trying to keep up with the sharpest scalpel on the surgical floor.
He had loved it.
Every impossible, brilliant, exhausting second of it. The night shifts. The trauma cases. The high that came from saving someone who shouldn’t have made it.
But then came Lucy.
Her death cracked something in him—deep and hidden and vital. And what followed was a spiral so fast, so vicious, he barely remembered hitting rock bottom. The drugs numbed the grief, until they didn’t. County became too much. Then everything became too much.
When Benton dropped him off at rehab—no words, just a firm hand on the wheel and a long silence—Carter had meant to come back. He really had. He told himself it was temporary. That he’d recover, regroup, return.
But once he was clean, the thought of County brought back everything: the flickering ER lights, the clatter of trauma carts, the code blues, Lucy’s blood on his hands. It was like holding a loaded syringe again. One whiff of that old world, and the cravings came screaming back.
So he cut the cord.
He took his mother’s maiden name. Moved to Pittsburgh. Reinvented himself as Dr. Robonavitch. Built a new reputation in a new city, brick by painful brick. And for a while, it worked. He stayed clean. He stayed sharp. He became someone else.
Until today.
Until the music festival that turned into a war zone. Until the blood started pouring in. Until Peter Benton was wheeled through his doors with a bullet in his shoulder and that same unshakable look in his eyes.
The past had a heartbeat again—and he’d just sent it up to the OR.
“You know him,” Jack said the moment they were out of earshot.
He nodded, checking a patient who had almost been trampled by the crowd. “I haven’t known Peter Benton in Twenty-Years,” he admitted. “I trained under him in Med School.”
“You went to Med School in Chicago?” Jack asked.
Robby fought the urge to laugh as he checked the man's vitals. “I was born in Chicago. Spent my entire life there until I moved to Pittsburgh.”
“Why did he call you Carter?” he asked.
“Because that’s my name,” he said, sighing. “John MIchael Carter. Robinavitch is my mother's maiden name.”
“But—”
“Jack,” Carter snapped, voice low but razor-sharp. “I’d love to stop and unpack this right now, I really would, but in case you missed it—this hospital is under siege. We have multiple GSWs, dozens critical. So unless you want to swap that clipboard for a scalpel, get out of my way.”
He didn’t wait for a reply. He was already moving—cutting through the chaos of the ER, past gurneys streaked with blood and floors slick with saline.
And then he saw Jake.
The kid sat crumpled in a folding chair near the wall, his arms limp at his sides, a blood-soaked bandage tied around one thigh like a haphazard tourniquet. His face was streaked with grime and dried tears, and he looked up at Carter with too much hope in his eyes—hope that cracked something deep in Carter’s chest.
“Hey,” Jake asked, voice trembling. “What’s going on? Is Leah...?”
God. He looked so young. Just a kid. Covered in someone else’s blood.
Carter knelt beside him, fighting the tremor in his own voice. He couldn’t lose it now. Jake didn’t need grief—he needed clarity. He needed strength. He needed to be strong for him.
“Leah’s injuries were... serious,” Carter said, carefully. “When she came in, she wasn’t breathing. We intubated her—put a tube down her throat to get oxygen in. Her lungs were collapsing under blood pressure, so we drained what we could. We gave her everything—fluids, blood, even her own from her chest cavity.”
He paused. Just for a second. Just long enough to collect the splintering edges of himself.
“But we couldn’t stay ahead of the bleeding. Her heart stopped.” He met Jake’s eyes. “You saw me. We did CPR. We tried—Jake, we did everything.”
Jake blinked, like trying to force the words into place. “She’s... dead?” His breath hitched. “No, no. I—I was talking to her after she got shot. She was awake. She said she was okay. There was a doctor... Peter. He helped her.”
Carter froze. “Peter? Peter Benton?”
Jake nodded quickly, wiping his face with a shaking hand. “Yeah. He used a belt on my leg—stopped the bleeding. He stayed with us.”
A small breath left Carter’s lips. Of course Peter had been there. Of course he had saved someone. Even now. You could take the doctor out of country, but you couldn’t take county out of the doctor.
“I’m sorry, Jake.” Carter’s voice cracked. “There was nothing more we could do.”
Jake was already shaking his head. “I want to see her.”
Carter hesitated. “I’m really sorry, but you can’t. It’s still an active FBI investigation. We can’t release any—”
“I know she’s dead!” Jake shouted, the words bursting from him like shrapnel. “But I need to see her. Please. Please, just—just let me say goodbye.”
Silence fell between them, carved from grief and flickering fluorescents.
Finally, Carter nodded. “Okay. Come with me.”
He led Jake through the back corridor, past supply closets and empty crash carts, to the pediatric wing—converted now into a temporary morgue. The air was colder here. Still. The kind of silence that hummed.
“Are you sure about this?” Carter asked quietly, hand on the door.
Jake nodded. “Yes.”
Inside, the room was dim and grim. Bodies were arranged in rows, each covered with pale blue sheets, numbered tags attached to exposed wrists.
Jake stopped just inside the door. “All these people... they’re dead?”
Carter nodded. “Yeah.”
Jake’s breath hitched again. “Which one is Leah?”
Carter stepped forward, gentle now, more guide than doctor. “Check your wristband. What number do you have?”
Jake looked down, the band smeared and wrinkled. “91”
Carter’s jaw clenched. He turned to the body in the center row. He reached down with a gloved hand and gently pulled the sheet back.
“I’m so sorry, Jake,” Carter whispered. His voice barely rose above the hum of the overhead lights. “This is her.”
Jake’s legs buckled. He collapsed to the floor beside the stretcher, his hands reaching for Leah’s like he could still warm them. His sobs came sharp and broken, shattering the sterile hush of the makeshift morgue like a dropped tray of instruments.
Carter stood back, hands clenched at his sides. The sterile air smelled faintly of bleach and blood, and it stung in his nose. He didn’t move. Didn’t breathe. Just watched Jake crumble, guarding him like a sentinel at a tomb.
“Did you...” Jake choked through his tears. “Did you call her parents?”
“They’ll get her number,” Carter said. “Our social worker will reach out. Very soon.”
Jake didn’t look up. His shoulders shook as he pressed his forehead to Leah’s cold hand.
“I got her killed,” he whispered. “This is my fault.”
“No,” Carter said quickly, sharply, like he could sever the thought before it took root. “This is not your fault.”
Jake’s voice cracked as he stared at the body. “Why couldn’t you save her? I mean—this is what you do .”
“I tried,” Carter said, voice hoarse. “We all tried. If this had been—God, if this had been any other day —”
Jake snapped his head up, grief flaring into fury. “Any other day? What the fuck does that mean? ‘Any other day?’ Are you saying you could’ve saved her?”
“Yes,” Carter said, too fast. Then: “No. I—I don’t know.”
The mask cracked. He turned away from Jake, hand scrubbing over his face, fingers trembling.
“I don’t know,” he muttered again, softer. “We're drowning up there. You’ve seen it. Gurneys in hallways. Kids on the floor. We’ve had dozens of gunshot victims in the last hour. And the fact that we’ve saved as many as we have is a goddamn miracle .”
“But not Leah.”
Carter flinched. Like the name alone was a punch. He hadn’t been able to save Lucy either…
“No. Not Leah,” he said, barely breathing.
He leaned heavily against the wall, his shoulders sagging like something had been knocked loose inside him. “You want numbers? I don’t know how many people I’ve helped today. I’ve lost count. But I can tell you the names of every single person who died.”
His eyes were far away now. Lost.
“There was Mr. Spencer—died in front of his kids. An eighteen-year-old girl, brain dead from fentanyl. A man with a blown valve in his heart. A little girl who drowned trying to save her baby sister.” His voice hitched. “And now Leah. Jesus. Leah.”
He pressed the heel of his palm to his forehead, like he could push the images out.
“I’m gonna remember her,” he said. “Long after you’ve forgotten. Fuck. ”
His breath caught, raw and ragged, as the edges of composure frayed. A full-body shudder went through him, like his own bones were betraying him. He backed toward the door, shaking his head, panic clawing up his throat.
“I’m sorry,” he choked. “I’m so fucking sorry. You—you gotta go. I can’t—Jake, I can’t do this. You gotta go. Please. You have to go.”
“Robby—wait. Robby! ” Jake stood, reaching for him as Carter stumbled toward the door.
Everything hit him like a freight train. Covid, Lucy, Leah—names and faces crashed into him in rapid succession, each one a wound torn open anew. He saw them all. The ones he’d treated, the ones he’d failed, the ones he’d watched die despite everything he’d thrown at the fire. The roar of it all—screams, alarms, flatlines—pressed in on him, deafening and inescapable. His hands had touched too many bodies that would never move again. His life was a graveyard, and he was the one who kept digging.
He wanted to scream. Or sob. Or disappear.
Now, for the first time, every one of those late-night calls with Abbot made perfect, shattering sense. Every time he'd steadied someone else's shaking hands, whispered them back from the edge—he hadn't realized how close he was to that same ledge. Not until the world tilted, and the past crashed violently into the present.
Two lives. Two compartments he’d sealed tight. And now? Collided. Bleeding into one another. A mess of pain and ghosts and things he couldn’t run from anymore.
He just wanted it to stop. All of it.
When Whiticker pulled him out of the pedes room, it felt like his limbs weren’t limbs at all, just dead weight—concrete and lead, dragging him into some unseen trench. He could barely register the hallway around him. Fluorescent lights smeared into abstract shapes above his head. His body moved, but he wasn’t in it.
And of all the goddamn people to witness his unraveling, it had to be Whitikker. Poor kid. Still too new to know when to look away.
“Dr. Robby.”
The voice snapped through the air like a whip—young, sharp, and too loud for the frayed thread his mind was hanging by. Both men flinched.
Oh God. He knew that voice.
No. Not now. Not him.
He wasn’t equipped to deal with Frank right now. Not when his pulse was a hammer in his throat, not when his vision kept blurring, not when the only thing holding him together was the sheer will not to fall apart in front of his team. Frank—damn him—was a friend, even if he said the stupidest shit sometimes. And Robby couldn’t take another hit, not from him. Not today. Not after everything. He’d been stabbed before, literally stabbed, and somehow that felt like a better day than this one.
He turned slowly, like he had to fight gravity just to move. Frank stood just a few feet away, washed in harsh overhead light. His face was pale, tight around the eyes and mouth, like he hadn’t slept in days. Like maybe he’d seen the same ghosts Robby had. He looked like a ghost himself—or worse, like a mirror. A grim reflection of who Robby used to be: wired with fear, smudged with guilt, barely holding on.
Robby’s heart clenched, one brutal, bitter thud. He couldn’t decide if it was pity or recognition.
He wasn’t angry about the benzos. Not really. Not deep down. But the day had carved him hollow, and when Frank had pushed—he’d snapped. Words he couldn’t take back had come out, edged with bitterness, honed on years of exhaustion. He regretted it the second they were out. But he couldn't patch it now. Not here. Not in front of Peter. Not like this.
Frank stepped forward, hesitant, hands twitching at his sides like they didn’t know whether to reach out or retreat. His eyes were wide and too bright, his voice tight and splintered at the edges. “Can I talk to you?” he asked, barely above a whisper—like speaking any louder might shatter him completely.
Robby didn’t turn. Not fully. Just a subtle shift of his stance, a pivot stiff with resistance, like even acknowledging Frank cost him something. His shoulder rose slightly, jaw clenched so hard it felt like his molars might crack.
“Really, Frank?” The words came out like gravel—low, cold, each syllable scraped raw by the weight of the day. “We’ll talk in the morning. Now’s not the time.”
There was a heartbeat of silence. Frank’s mouth opened, desperate to argue.
“But Dr—”
“Carter,” Peter cut in, voice calm and practiced.. Robby hadn’t even realized he’d stopped directly in front of him until he’d spoken. He’d been too worried about everything else. Peter had been watching. Listening. He wondered if he saw the dried tears, or if he saw him enter the Pedes room.
Something about the way Peter said his name— Carter —was deliberate. A quiet reminder of who he used to be, and could never be again.
Peter’s gaze flicked to Frank, then back to Robby. He tilted his head slightly, expression carefully neutral, but his eyes were sharp. “Why don’t you introduce me to your friend?” he asked, his tone light, almost casual, but there was weight underneath. An undercurrent. Like he was offering them both an out.
Robby’s mouth was dry. He could feel his pulse in his throat. His mask of professionalism wavered, just for a second.
Frank was still staring at him, hope and hurt bleeding together across his face.
Robby exhaled sharply through his nose. His shoulders slumped with a reluctant sigh, the exhaustion hanging off him like a soaked coat. He hadn’t slept in—what? Twenty-four hours? More? He was unraveling and he knew it.
“This is Dr. Frank Langdon,” he said flatly. “Frank, this is Peter Benton. I did my residency with him.”
Peter gave the kid a once-over, that practiced surgeon’s gaze assessing every inch. “Nice to meet you, Dr. Langdon,” he said. “Are you two okay? Things looked a little heated.”
Frank hesitated. His lip trembled, just slightly. “I—”
“Frank,” Robby said gently, but firmly. “We will talk. But not now. I’m fried, and you’re spiraling. This isn’t the time or the place. Go home. Get some rest. We’ll talk tomorrow—when we both have clear heads.”
“Dr. Robby,” Frank said, his voice cracking. “You have to understand—”
“I do understand,” Robby said, his voice rising before he could stop it. “ Trust me , Frank—I understand more than you think.” His hands were trembling now. He stuffed them in his coat pockets.
Frank looked at him, face pale with disbelief and anger. “Robby, you have no fucking clue what I’m going through.”
That was it. He snapped.
“Goddamn it, Frank,” Robby hissed, barely able to hold himself together. “I have been in your exact same shoes. You’re addicted to benzos? Be glad it’s not fentanyl. That was my drug of choice.”
Frank blinked. “Wait—what? You were addicted?”
He ran a hand through his hair, ignoring the stare of Dana who had overheard everything.
“Yes, I had an addiction, and I went to rehab for it,” Robby said, voice stripped bare now. “I was put on painkillers for my back. But, I just ended up shooting Fentynal in a trauma room.”
“I—”
“We can talk about this later, Frank,” he said. “Right now I am running on no sleep, my son’s girlfriend is dead, it's the anniversary of Adamson’s death, oh and My ex-girlfriend just had a misscarriage. I’m exhausted and I don’t want to say something I regret. Just go home.”
“What happened?” he said. “What made you so addicted?” God, why couldn’t this kid leave well enough alone. What part of I might say something I regret, did he not understand?
“I was stabbed. In my own hospital by a patient. My med student—Lucy—she didn’t make it. I had to watch her bleed out for half an hour before anyone found us. I lived. And then I unraveled. The painkillers became the only thing that made it quiet. The only thing that made me feel like I was still human.”
Frank was speechless. His mouth opened. Closed. “I didn’t know.”
“No one does,” Robby said, his voice like gravel. “Except Peter.” He tried not to glance at him but failed. Peter was watching him with soft eyes—too soft—like he was staring at something broken. Something he used to know.
Robby couldn’t stand it.
“It gets better,” he said, turning back to Frank. “No matter how low you feel. No matter how far gone you think you are. It can get better. I thought my life was over. But I had doctors who fought for me. Who didn’t give up. And I’m not giving up on you.”
Frank’s eyes were glassy now, mouth pressed tight like he was holding something in.
“But right now?” Robby added. “Right now, we both need sleep. I’ll talk to you tomorrow. Okay?”
Frank nodded slowly, the fire drained from his posture. “Thank you for telling me,” he said at last—his voice quieter, more vulnerable. The way he looked at Robby made his skin crawl.
“He’s a lot like you,” Peter said quietly, eyes tracking the door Frank had disappeared through. “Back when you were younger.”
Robby let out a tired breath, something halfway between a laugh and a sigh. “It’s like staring into a goddamn mirror. He even has the same bad haircut,” he murmured, rubbing a hand down his face. “Same drive. Same recklessness. Same anger.” He paused, glancing at the scuffed linoleum floor like it held the answers. “I think he’ll manage it better than I did, though. He’s got a wife. Kids. Something to tether him. He’ll be okay.”
“Did you not have anyone, Car—Robby?’
“I did,” he said. “But, I pushed everyone away.” He smiled slightly at him. “Get some rest, Peter. An OR just opened up. You’re next for surgery.”
“Carter—-” he said, but he didn’t listen. “Robby.”
He kept walking.
When Peter woke up, he was in a completely different room.
Every inch of his body screamed. A deep, bone-weary ache pulsed through him, radiating out from his torso. His left side throbbed with something sharper—something surgical. Bandages were tightly wrapped around his abdomen. His right arm was taped down with an IV line snaking into the crook of his elbow, a cannula looped around his nostrils delivering oxygen.
Peter tried to move, but it was like being pinned to the bed by invisible weights. Even shifting his fingers sent sparks of pain up his arm. He let out a low, involuntary groan.
A soft rustling came from his right, and a nurse appeared at his bedside. She couldn’t have been older than twenty, her curly dark hair pulled back into a tight ponytail, eyes wide and alert behind thin-framed glasses. She smiled when she saw his eyes open.
“You’re awake,” she said gently, relief in her voice. “Hi there.”
Her voice was warm, but there was tension behind it—a kind of professional caution that told Peter this wasn’t the first time she’d seen someone like him wake up after a shooting.
“I’ll let the doctor know you’re up,” the nurse said, already halfway to the door. Her sneakers whispered across the linoleum, the soft squeak of rubber echoing faintly in the sterile quiet of the room.
Peter stirred, the motion tugging at something deep in his chest. He tried to speak—to ask where Reese was—but the effort snagged in his throat. All that came out was a rasp, thin and dry as paper.
The nurse turned at the sound, her expression tightening with immediate concern. “Don’t try to talk yet, okay? You’ve got a lot of healing to do.” Her voice was gentle, but firm, the kind of practiced reassurance that had comforted hundreds of patients before him.
Then she was gone, slipping through the curtain like a ghost, leaving Peter alone beneath the fluorescent glare. The machines around him beeped in steady rhythm, too regular to be comforting. Pain pulsed dully at his side, threading outward in waves that made the edges of the world swim. Confusion sat heavy in his chest, like smoke that wouldn’t clear, and beneath it all was fear—residual and primal—clinging like cobwebs he couldn’t shake loose.
Minutes passed. Or maybe longer. Time had gone strange.
The curtain rustled again.
A man stepped through—older, broad-shouldered, a calm confidence in the way he moved. Peter recognized him from earlier, before the world had gone sideways. Jack, he thought Carter had called him.
“Hey,” the man said, offering a small, tired smile. His voice was deep, but gentle. “Welcome to the land of the living.”
Peter blinked slowly, as if dragging himself up from underwater. His tongue felt like a sandbag against the roof of his mouth. “Is Dr. Carter here?” he asked, voice hoarse, the name slipping out before he could stop it.
Jack’s brows lifted slightly. “Carter?”
Peter grimaced, shifting slightly in the bed—too fast. Pain lanced through his shoulder, sharp and immediate. He gritted his teeth. “Sorry. I meant… Dr. Robonavitch.”
Understanding flickered across Jack’s face. “Ah. Robby.” He nodded and stepped closer, reaching up to adjust the telemetry leads. “Yeah. His shift just started, I think.”
Jack glanced down at Peter, a subtle curiosity in his expression. “You two know each other?”
Peter gave a dry, sandpapery laugh. “You could say that. I trained him. Back when he didn’t know his ass from a stethoscope.”
Jack blinked. “ Seriously? You’re the one who taught him?”
“Sort of,” Peter said, easing back into the pillows, eyes half-lidded with the effort. “He was a pain in my ass. Didn’t even know how to place an IV when I met him.”
Jack chuckled, shaking his head as he checked the IV line at Peter’s wrist, fingers deft and practiced. “Hard to imagine. These days, he’s the one they call when everyone else is stumped. I’ve seen him pull off stuff most of us wouldn’t dare try.”
Peter’s lips twitched—somewhere between pride and disbelief. He let his eyes fall closed again, just for a moment. “Yeah,” he murmured. “He always did learn fast.”
Jack moved around the bed, fingers tapping at a small screen. His movements were efficient but unhurried. “Vitals are holding steady. Your oxygen’s solid. The bullet passed clean through—missed anything life-threatening by about an inch. We repaired the shattered bone and the muscle damage. You were lucky, Dr. Benton. Very lucky.”
Peter didn’t reply right away. He just let the words settle over him like a blanket, frayed and heavy. For the first time since waking, his lungs didn’t feel quite so tight.
“We’ll keep you comfortable,” Jack added, his tone shifting from professional to kind. “You need anything—press that call button. I’ll let Robby know you’re awake.”
Peter gave a faint nod of acknowledgment, already sinking back down into the mattress. His eyelids fluttered once… twice… and then gave in to gravity.
The last thing he heard was the quiet click of the curtain being drawn shut behind Jack—and then the soft, rhythmic beep of the monitors, lulling him back under.
When he woke again, Peter stirred against the crisp sheets, the dull ache in his shoulder flaring into sharp awareness. Everything smelled like antiseptic and plastic tubing. Machines beeped softly beside him. His mouth was dry. His head felt stuffed with cotton.
God, he fucking hated hospitals.
Robby stepped into view, clipboard tucked under one arm, stethoscope already looped around his neck. “Peter,” he said, voice even. “How are you feeling?”
Peter blinked blearily at him. That question again.
“How do you think I’m feeling?” he muttered. “I’ve been shot.”
Robby chuckled under his breath, tugging his stethoscope from around his neck. “Fair point.” He pulled back the blanket and gently unbuttoned the top of Peter’s gown. “I’ll try not to take that personally.”
Peter winced as cold air hit his skin. Robby pressed the stethoscope to his chest with practiced ease.
“Deep breath,” he said.
Peter inhaled slowly, the movement tugging at his injured shoulder. “Yeah,” he hissed. “Hurts like a bitch.”
“I bet.” Robby shifted the diaphragm slightly, listening carefully to his lungs. “No signs of pneumothorax. That’s good.”
He stepped back, scribbled something quickly on the chart, then set it aside and gently took Peter’s wrist to check his pulse.
“I never got the chance to thank you,” he said, eyes on the ticking second hand of his watch. “You helped Jake.”
Peter’s brow furrowed. “Jake?” He let the name roll around in his foggy mind before it clicked. “The kid behind the truck?”
“Yeah.” Robby nodded, releasing his wrist. “He’s my stepson.”
Peter blinked. “Seriously?” He couldn’t hide the surprise in his voice. “You have a stepson ?”
“Terrifying, right?” Robby gave a crooked smile as he moved to adjust Peter’s IV line. “He sort of hates me right now. But… at least he’s alive. Because of you. So, thank you.”
Peter nodded, a quiet beat passing between them.
“The girl,” he asked, after a pause. “Leah. Did she…”
Robby froze mid-movement, then slowly resumed, his voice lower. “No. She didn’t make it. Hence the hatred.”
Peter’s gaze dropped. “I’m sorry.”
“Me too,” Robby said, checking the monitor, fingers brushing the screen like it might offer some comfort. “Honestly, the fact that we saved anyone is a miracle.”
He hesitated, then looked back down at Peter. “I have a surprise for you, by the way.”
Peter raised a skeptical eyebrow. “Surprise?”
Before Robby could answer, Peter’s eyes drifted past him—and widened.
His breath caught in his throat.
“ Reese? ” he whispered, like he couldn’t trust his own eyes. Then louder, more urgent: “ Reese! ”
Robby stepped aside just in time for Reese to rush past him, sneakers squeaking on the floor.
“ Dad! ” Reese cried, launching toward the bed.
Peter half-sat up, gritting through the pain, arms reaching for his son like instinct. IV lines pulled taut. Monitors spiked.
He pulled Reese into a shaking hug, burying his face into the boy’s shoulder, as if needing to physically feel that he was real. His entire body trembled with the release of relief, disbelief, and something dangerously close to joy.
Robby stood frozen for a second, throat thick, jaw clenched. He looked away, blinking fast, forcing his hands to steady as he reattached a loose ECG lead.
For a flicker of time, the crushing weight he carried lifted.
He turned to leave, already reaching for the curtain.
“Wait—Car— Dr. Robby, ” Peter called, voice still ragged but clearer now.
Robby paused and turned, one hand already on the curtain.
Their eyes met.
And just for a second, it wasn’t Dr. Michael Robinavitch standing in that room—it was John Carter.
“Will you be okay?” he asked.
He smiled. “I always am.”
“Don’t be a stranger this time,” he said. “I know you want to forget all of us. But, we never forgot you. Maybe pay us old people at County a visit. Weaver might faint if she saw you.”
“I’ll think about it,” he told him, and Peter could tell he meant it.
It had been twenty years since he’d last set foot in Chicago.
The city skyline still cut across the sky like a row of jagged teeth, and the wind off the lake was just as biting as he remembered. But it was the hospital that struck him hardest. County General stood like a stubborn old sentinel—worn, weathered, but still standing.
The brick exterior hadn’t been washed in decades, the paint around the ER entrance faded and peeling in long, lazy curls. The same rusted basketball hoop was mounted above the rear door near the ambulance bay, its net long gone, leaving only a tired ring swaying slightly in the breeze.
Robby stood still for a moment, letting the wind whip through his coat, the smell of car exhaust and hospital-grade sanitizer wafting faintly from the sliding doors. It was like stepping into a memory that hadn’t bothered to age.
Some things, he thought, no matter how badly you want them to, never change.
He stepped closer to the entrance, and that’s when he saw him—a young doctor, maybe late twenties, in wrinkled scrubs and a white coat that looked two sizes too big. He was perched on the edge of a bench just outside the ER doors, cupping his hands around a cigarette like he was guarding fire from the gods.
The doctor squinted up at him, taking a drag. “Can I help you?” he asked, exhaling a thin ribbon of smoke into the cold air.
He was caught slightly off guard by the familiarity of the question, the setting. He hadn’t seen a cigarette in a doctor’s hand since med school. The smell made his stomach churn—not from temptation, but from memory. He was suddenly, acutely grateful he’d dropped that short-lived habit.
Robby blinked, the question catching him off guard, dragging him out of a fog of old memories and into the sharp chill of the Chicago air. The wind tugged at his coat, and he stepped closer to the hospital entrance, his eyes narrowing at the thin wisp of smoke curling into the overcast sky.
“Sorry?” Robby asked, stepping forward, the gravel crunching faintly beneath his shoes.
The young doctor looked up, eyes squinting against the wind. He tapped ash onto the concrete, nodding toward him. “I said, can I help you?”
There was a beat of silence. Robby tucked his hands into his coat pockets, shoulders drawn up against the cold. “Yeah,” he said. His voice came quiet but steady. “I’m looking for Peter Benton.”
The name landed with a faint pause.
The kid raised one eyebrow, curiosity flickering in his eyes. “Dr. Benton? Do you have an appointment?”
Robby gave a half-smile—wry, a little weary. “No. Just… tell him John Carter’s here to see him.”
For a second, the only sound was the wind and the soft crackle of the cigarette. The kid stared at him, the name clearly ringing a bell.
“John Carter?” he echoed, like he was trying the taste of it.
Robby gave a small nod.
Recognition dawned, slow and dawning. The cigarette wobbled slightly between the young man’s fingers before he stubbed it out against the bench.
“Feel free to go in,” he said, standing and brushing ash from his coat. “He gets off in a few hours, I think.”
“Thanks,” Robby said. Then paused, giving the kid a once-over. “What’s your name?”
“Ben Ross,” the young man replied.
Robby blinked again. “Ross? You wouldn’t happen to be related to Doug Ross, would you?”
The kid looked surprised—head tilting, a grin tugging at the corner of his mouth. “Yeah. He’s my dad.”
Carter let out a quiet laugh, disbelief and time catching up with him in the same breath. “Jesus. Has it really been that long? Your dad and I used to work together here. In this exact building. He still kicking?”
“Yeah,” Ben said. “Just retired last year.”
“Crazy,” Robby said, shaking his head. “Tell your old man I say hi.”
“I will,” Ben nodded. “You still working?”
“Yeah,” Robby replied, slipping his hands deeper into his coat. “I run the Pittsburgh trauma center now.”
Ben’s eyebrows shot up. “No shit. So you were there when Dr. Benton was shot last year, weren’t you?”
“I was,” Robby said. His voice quieted, touched by something heavier. “It was… a hell of a day. But we got through it.”
Ben exhaled, almost reverently. “They give lectures about that day, you know? At Med school. They say it’s the gold standard in trauma coordination. Everyone talks about the attending over there—Robinavitch, I think? They say he’s the best in the country.”
Robby blinked again. He didn’t realize people were talking about him. “Yeah,” he said. “I’ve heard good things.”
Ben grinned. “I’m thinking about applying out there when I graduate. Figured it wouldn’t hurt to shoot high.”
Robby smiled faintly, warmth flickering in his eyes. “I’ll put in a good word for you.”
“Thanks, Dr. Carter,” Ben said, the words tinged with both reverence and something hopeful—like he'd just met a legend and didn’t even realize it until the moment passed.
Carter chuckled, soft and dry. The sound felt strange in his own throat, like something unused for too long. “Anytime, kid,” he said, then paused, pivoting back slightly. “Oh—and call me Robby. I don’t go by Dr. Carter anymore.”
Ben blinked, confused. “Robby? What’s that short for?”
Carter smirked, just the barest quirk of his lips. “Robinavitch,” he said, tossing the name over his shoulder as he stepped through the sliding doors and into the familiar hum of County General.
The emergency room looked both completely unchanged and utterly foreign. The overhead lights still buzzed faintly, the linoleum still gleamed in places it shouldn't, and the air still carried that same unmistakable cocktail of antiseptic, old coffee, and adrenaline. But the faces were different. The tempo had shifted. He felt like a ghost walking through someone else’s memory.
“Can I help you?” a nurse called out, her voice polite but efficient. She glanced up from her computer, one eyebrow lifted in question.
“Yeah,” Carter replied, stepping up to the desk. “I’m looking for Peter Benton.”
She gave a slight nod. “He’s in surgery right now. Can I help you in any other way?”
Carter hesitated, his eyes scanning the floor for a moment like he was trying to find the year. “Is Kerry Weaver here?”
The nurse glanced at a clipboard. “She’s with a patient, but she should be out any minute.”
“Thanks,” he said. His eyes flicked to a nearby hallway, a shadow of memory tugging at him. “Does Abby Lockhart still work here? Or Jing-Mei? Luka?”
The nurse shook her head, offering an apologetic smile. “No, I’m sorry. They both moved on a while ago. Did you… used to work here?”
“Yeah,” he said, the word coming out more like a breath than an answer. “It’s been about twenty years.”
She looked at him for a second longer, studying him as if trying to place a face she should remember.
Then, from behind him, a familiar voice cut through the ambient din of the ER.
“John?”
He turned, startled—not just by the sound of his name, but by the sudden lurch in his chest. Kerry Weaver stood just a few feet away, still with her cane, her expression flickering between disbelief and something warmer. Older. Wiser. And worn, in that way only County General ever managed to etch into a person.
Carter gave a half smile—tentative, wary—unsure whether to expect a hug, a slap, or a pointed lecture. “Hey, Kerry.”
Weaver didn’t move at first. She just stood there, her gaze scanning his face like she was flipping through an old photo album in her head. Her eyes narrowed—not in suspicion, but in disbelief—like she was trying to match the man in front of her with the memory of the young doctor who used to chase code blues like his life depended on them.
“John Carter?” she said slowly, the name strange on her tongue. She blinked once. “Is it really you?”
“In the flesh,” he said, spreading his hands slightly. “What’s left of it, anyway.”
She laughed—a quiet, surprised sound. The click of her cane echoed faintly as she stepped closer. The corners of her mouth tugged into a half-smile, equal parts fondness and caution. “I almost didn’t recognize you.”
He dipped his head, eyes dropping for a beat. “Yeah. I’ve, uh… been gone a while.”
“You look good,” she said. “And alive.”
Robby smirked, his eyes scanning her face, tracing the familiar lines, the signs of time and wear. There was a flicker of recognition, a knowing. Weaver. Same as ever. He exhaled slowly, feeling the tension in his shoulders loosen just a fraction. “I hear that’s still the standard around here.”
Weaver gave a short laugh despite herself. But her eyes stayed sharp, never softening. There was no time for pleasantries here. She’d always been like that—focused, precise, cutting straight to the point.
“Where have you been? Why now?”
He let out a slow breath, leaning against the worn counter, the hum of the overhead lights almost too loud. Why now? It wasn’t a simple answer, but Robby found himself thinking about it, the weight of her question settling in his chest. “Pittsburgh,” he said, the words coming easy, too easy. “I’m running trauma there now.”
Weaver tilted her head, eyes narrowing, like she could see through the layers of a story Robby hadn’t told yet. “No, you’re not. Some other guy is. Robinavitch—that’s the name we keep hearing.”
Robby smirked, a crooked, knowing grin. Here it comes. “That’s me. Robinavitch is my mother’s name. Most people just call me Robby now.”
Weaver’s jaw slackened, her eyebrows shooting up as though she hadn’t quite heard him right. “You’re Robinavitch?”
His smile faltered, just for a split second. The name felt foreign now, like an old coat that didn’t quite fit anymore. But it was still a part of him, a part that never left. “Guilty.”
Weaver barked out a laugh that turned a few heads, the sound a mix of disbelief and amusement. How long’s it been since I heard that? Robby thought. Too long. “You son of a bitch. You’ve been making national news. Peter told me what happened at that festival, but he didn’t mention you were the one in charge.”
His smile faded slightly, the corners of his mouth tightening. The words festival and shooting always carried a weight, a heaviness that had settled into his bones. Robby wasn’t one for nostalgia, but that day— God, that day —it felt like it never left him. “It was a bad day. We did what we had to do.”
There was a pause. Thick, heavy with unspoken history. Robby looked past her, his gaze drifting to the sterile, scuffed tiles on the floor. The hum of the fluorescent lights filled the space between them. He remembered this —the clamor of the ER, the ever-present urgency, the weight of every life in their hands. And the cost of it.
Weaver’s expression softened, the hardness around her eyes softening just a touch. She tapped her cane twice on the floor, the sound sharp in the quiet of the hallway. “And you figured out you weren’t John Carter anymore?”
Robby met her eyes again, the ghost of a smile playing at the corner of his lips. John Carter. That kid… He let the thought linger for a second, then pushed it away. "That kid’s still in there,” he said quietly. “But these days, I think he just lets me drive."
Before she could respond, a voice cut through the corridor, sharp and disbelieving.
“No fucking way—Carter?”
Both of them turned in surprise, the voice familiar, but distant— Susan? Robby felt a twinge of something—nostalgia, maybe, or the slow, familiar ache of seeing old faces after too long. Dr. Susan Lewis stood in the doorway of the nurses’ station, eyes wide, jaw slack, like she couldn’t quite believe her own eyes.
“Susan Lewis,” Robby said, his voice warmer now—still cautious, but the mischief that had once defined him crept back. God, I’d forgotten what it felt like to joke with her. “As I live and breathe.”
“We all thought you were dead,” she said, walking closer, tentative. She wasn’t quite sure whether he was real or a ghost—she’d never had that problem with him before. But then again, neither had he.
A younger doctor peered around her shoulder, clipboard clutched tightly in his chest, his face a mixture of confusion and awe. His ID read “Dr. Greg Murphy.” He blinked, like he was seeing a relic from another era. “Can someone tell me what’s going on?”
Weaver turned toward him, raising a finger like she was conducting traffic. “Greg,” she said, voice authoritative. “This is Dr—”
“Robinavitch,” Robby cut in quickly, his hand outstretched. He needed to ground himself in something, anything that could break the tension. “Most people call me Robby. I, uh, used to work here. Twenty years ago.”
Greg took his hand, his confusion still written all over his face, but there was respect in his posture. “It’s great to meet you,” he said, his voice eager but cautious. “It’s only my first day. I just graduated.”
“Congratulations,” Robby said with a sincere nod. “That’s no easy feat.”
“Wait,” another young doctor added, stepping forward, the wheels turning in his head. “You’re that Robinavitch? From Pittsburgh? The one from the shooting?”
Susan blinked, her mind catching up with the conversation. Then she turned back to Robby, the weight of the realization setting in. “Wait, that was you? What’s with the name change?”
“Robinovitch is my mother's name,” he explained. “I just needed a new start after everything that happened Susan.”
“They gave you a Castle Connolly Award,” Greg added, his voice low, reverent. He looked like he was standing in front of a legend. “112 people came into your emergency room, and only 6 people died.” His eyes widened, like he was in the presence of a myth.
Before Robby could respond, another voice broke through the noise—a low, familiar tone that cut straight through the years.
“What are you all doing standing around—” The voice paused, breath hitching on recognition. “Robby?”
Robby turned slowly, his smile blooming slow and crooked. There it was— Peter. In all his intensity, his controlled chaos, his underlying concern. “Hey, Peter.”
Dr. Peter Benton stood a few paces away, his expression somewhere between shock and something unreadable—pride, maybe, or disbelief. He was still Peter —solid, dependable, the kind of guy you wanted in your corner when everything else fell apart.
“You came?” Benton asked, his voice rougher than it had been seconds ago. The shock was still there, but beneath it, something else simmered—a question that went beyond just the here and now.
“Yeah,” Robby said softly, his voice quieter than usual. "Sorry it wasn’t earlier. I’ve been struggling to get the time off."
Susan turned toward Benton, her gaze sharp as a scalpel. “Why the fuck didn’t you tell us Carter was alive?”
Peter’s mouth tugged into a small, tired shrug, like he’d been carrying that burden for too long. “Wasn’t my story to tell.”
A nurse’s voice cut through the chaos: “GSW! ETA three minutes!”
The ER came alive in an instant, every second spent preparing for the storm. People moved with urgency—gloves snapping, gowns rushing, carts wheeling. The air hummed with controlled chaos.
Peter glanced at Robby, his voice carrying that familiar edge. “You feel like having a little fun? For old time’s sake?”
Robby didn’t miss a beat, pulling on gloves with a quick, sure motion. "Always. Let’s see what we’ve got." His mind raced, muscles already tightening in anticipation. No time to think, only to act. This was the kind of pressure he thrived under—the kind that made everything else fade away.
Greg Murphy trailed behind them, clipboard clutched tightly to his chest, eyes darting anxiously as he tried to keep pace with the veterans. The sweat at his brow told the story before he even said anything. Robby couldn’t help but notice the kid’s nerves. It was a look he’d worn too many times himself—too many times to count.
They rolled the gurney into Trauma 2. The patient—a young male, pale and clammy—was already fading fast. Blood pooled beneath him, dark and thick.
The paramedic didn’t waste time. “GSW to the left abdomen, through-and-through. BP’s dropping, 80/40. Heart rate’s 130. We got one unit of saline in, no response. He’s still alert, but he’s slipping.”
Robby was already at the patient’s side, voice cutting through the tension like a blade. “Two large-bore IVs. 18-gauge. Get the blood ready. Page the OR—this kid’s not going upstairs, he’s going to the table, now.”
Greg’s eyes darted around the room, but his hands hovered uncertainly, his gaze locked on the blood steadily pouring from the wound. Robby knew that look all too well. The moment when everything seemed to slow down, when the weight of the situation threatened to crush you.
“Greg!” Susan’s voice was sharp, impatient. “What are you doing? Get in here!”
Greg flinched, his hands trembling slightly. Robby didn’t have time to wait for him to gather himself. He moved in, stepping between Greg and the patient with surgical precision, his voice low but commanding.
“Look at me.”
Greg’s wide eyes locked onto his, panic simmering just below the surface. Robby’s calm presence was a lifeline.
“You’re not alone,” Robby said, his voice cold but reassuring. “You’ve got this.”
“I—I don’t know if I can—”
“You will,” Robby interrupted, his eyes narrowing in that way that left no room for doubt. “Because you set the tone, Dr. Murphy.”
The words landed hard. Greg’s posture shifted, his breath evening out. It was the push he needed—Robby could see it in his eyes. The kid wasn’t frozen anymore. He was on the clock now.
“He’s going to need a central line,” Greg barked, his confidence rising.
“Now you're talking, Dr. Murphy,” Robby smiled, his mind already calculating the next steps. "Why exactly does he need a central line?"
Greg didn’t hesitate. "He’s losing volume fast, Sir. With his BP this low, we can’t risk peripheral IVs anymore. He’s going to need rapid access to administer fluids and blood, especially since he's not responding to the saline. The central line will allow us to push the volume he needs and maintain pressure while we prep for surgery."
Robby nodded, his gaze never leaving Greg. “Good thinking. Let’s get it done.”
The trauma bay pulsed with rapid, focused energy. Benton was applying clamps to the left iliac artery while Susan monitored the vitals. The patient let out a weak groan, his body still holding on. The monitor showed a slight rise in the blood pressure, stabilizing briefly.
Robby felt a momentary calm, just a flicker. It wasn’t about the rush. Not anymore. It was the quiet knowledge that every decision, every action, was a calculated move to save this kid.
“Let’s get him up to the OR,” Robby said once the patient was stable enough. “He’ll be fine.”
“You glad to be back, Robby?” Peter asked, taking off his gloves.
Robby looked at the chaos around him—the faces, the decisions, the lives in their hands. It was like nothing had changed. And yet everything had.
“Yeah,” he smiled, that familiar feeling settling in his chest. "I think I am."