Mistakes

Series Metadata

Listing Series

• Mistakes by MileyCyprus_Hill

  Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption 2, rdr2 - Fandom  

  • Mature
  • No Archive Warnings Apply
  • F/M
  • Complete Work

  08 Jul 2020

  Tags

  • No Archive Warnings Apply
  • Arthur Morgan/Reader
  • Arthur Morgan
  • John Marston
  • Hosea Matthews
  • Dutch van der Linde
  • Original Characters
  • Original Female Character(s)
  • Original Male Character(s)
  • Original Child Character(s)
  • arthur morgan - Freeform
  • RDR2
  • red dead redemption 2 - Freeform
  • Smut
  • NSFW
  • Mentions of Suicide
  • mature - Freeform
  • Childbirth
  • Unplanned Pregnancy
  • Love
  • pre blackwater
  • Young Arthur Morgan
  • Papa Arthur Morgan
  • Guilt
  • Love Triangle
  • Mary Linton - Freeform
  • Mary Gillis
  • 10 years before in-game start
  • Panic Attack
  • Trigger Warnings
  • Angst

  Summary

  Pre-Blackwater by at least 10 years. Arthur is 26 years old, reader is 20, and John Marston is 16. Arthur has just broken off his engagement with Mary. Instead of the one-night stand with Eliza, Arthur sleeps with the reader with similar consequences.

  Series

  • Part 1 of Mistakes

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  36,066

  Chapters:

  7/7

  Comments:

  97

  Kudos:

  492

  Bookmarks:

  59

  Hits:

  9,908

• Penance by MileyCyprus_Hill

  Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games), Red Dead Redemption 2  

  • Mature
  • No Archive Warnings Apply
  • F/M
  • Work in Progress

  07 Aug 2025

  Tags

  • No Archive Warnings Apply
  • Arthur Morgan & Reader
  • Arthur Morgan & You
  • Arthur Morgan/Reader
  • Abigail Roberts Marston/John Marston
  • Arthur Morgan
  • Dutch van der Linde
  • Hosea Matthews
  • John Marston
  • Abigail Roberts Marston
  • Tilly Jackson
  • Micah Bell
  • Van der Linde Gang Members (Red Dead Redemption)
  • Angst
  • Fluff and Angst
  • Broken Families
  • Angst with a Happy Ending
  • Slow Burn

  Series

  • Part 2 of Mistakes

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  2,240

  Chapters:

  1/?

  Comments:

  6

  Kudos:

  29

  Bookmarks:

  5

  Hits:

  349