Work Text:
This may just possibly be one of the worst and least productive things that could have happened.
You were currently having to try to figure out how to fix the multiverse. Something that up until a day or two ago you didn't have much knowledge of in the first place. Now you also had to play chaperone to four versions of the man you had just started dating.
"Hey!! Moe, Larry, Curly, Shemp... You wanna knock it off?! It's really hard to concentrate with the four of you arguing constantly and over the stupidest shit."
You rubbed your eyes before moving to rub your temples. You were exhausted and could already feel the migraine coming from having to play referee all day. You had drawn the short straw and had to play babysitter. To be fair, Wong would probably have run out of patience with them a long time ago.
A big part of the problem was they all thought they were right all of the time, so everything devolved into a debate over who was wrong and which of them was the smartest. You were a breath away from calling Dr. Raynor to make a house call and make them do the now infamous "soul gazing" exercise she had used with Sam and Bucky.
It also didn't help that they all liked to flirt with you and that would inevitably end with one making the other three jealous if they even thought you were flirting back. There was definitely no rule book on how to handle this. The closest was the movie Multiplicity and a Treehouse Of Horror episode of The Simpson's.
To eliminate any issues with addressing them you had given each of them some sort of nickname. It was either that or write numbers on their foreheads in Sharpie. Your original Stephen was just Doctor Strange, or Original Stephen. The one without the goatee earned the nickname Supreme Strange, because he constantly mentioned being Sorcerer Supreme. The one with the ponytail was part of a group that called themselves The Defenders, ergo he was Defender Strange. The last one was overall a bit spooky and had some more dark qualities. He became Sinister Strange.
To say this was putting stress on your new relationship with the original Doctor Strange was an understatement. You had just started sleeping together and now with the other three in the Sanctum it made having any alone time next to impossible. So not only were they mentally starting to wear on you, being around four of the man you were very physically attracted to had you sexually frustrated pretty much 24 hours a day.
When they weren't fighting it wasn't uncommon for fantasies to be playing in your mind of having two, or three, or frankly all four of them take you at once. You knew how good Original Stephen was at taking you apart. Would the others be able to read your body just as well? Could they make you cum as quickly and as hard? Were they all the same size? Nice and long, the perfect thickness with those nice prominent veins that felt so good inside you. Did the same little tricks make them go crazy when you were sucking their cocks. You loved sucking Stephen off. Watching such a powerful man be at the mercy of you and your skilled tongue was intoxicating.
You wondered how Supreme Strange's clean shaven face would feel between your legs eating you out. You were sure Sinister Strange would plow you so hard you wouldn't know your own name by the time he was done. Defender Strange? Well you really wanted to yank on his ponytail as you rode him. Plus truth be told, getting gangbanged had always been a little fantasy of yours. Having it be four of the same man fucking you had never even been considered.
You had an inkling they could all tell when your thoughts veered into the X-rated though. Your Original Stephen would quirk his eyebrows at you and get a confident smirk on his face. Supreme Strange would lick and bite his lips a lot, as well as bring his hand up to rub at his chin. Sinister would look at you like he was already undressing and fucking you in his head. Defender Strange would find little ways to touch you. He'd make sure his fingertips lingered on yours when he handed you something, or touch the small of your back when he would move behind you.
You knew it was a complete pipe dream. The four of them couldn't be in the same room without arguing, there was no way they would agree to share you that way. No, that fantasy would surely stay relegated to the time you would spend alone with your favorite toys. You just couldn't get the way they would all look at you out of your head though. The little glances they would all give you. Even as you sat here now, listening to them bicker.
You were finally at your breaking point, "Oh my God, will you just all shut up for five minutes?! If you aren't all going to fuck me I don't want to hear or see any of you for the next few hours!"
With that you stormed off to your bedroom, or at least the one you were staying in until this all got worked out. It hadn't really dawned on you what you had just screamed at them until you shut the door behind you. You brought your hands up over your face and let out a little shriek of panic. You walked over to the bed and fell face first into it. Maybe you would get really lucky and the bed would just swallow you up whole.
You were too wrapped up in trying to figure out a way to play off what you said as a joke to hear the door open. It wasn't until you heard a voice that you looked up.
"Oh darling, is that what you really wanted?" It was your Stephen. The other three were standing in the doorway behind him. He confidently strode across the room and came to sit next to you on the bed. He reached down and gently placed one hand under your chin. Tilting your head up to meet his gaze before bringing his lips down to softly but passionately caress yours. He pulled back with a smirk.
"If that is what has had you wound so tightly you could have just asked us."
"We did wonder what naughty little thoughts were rolling around in the pretty little head of yours. Your poker face isn't nearly as good as you think it is."
It was Sinister Strange addressing you this time. Stalking towards the bed like he was a predator hunting his prey. He settled on your other side and took no time bringing one hand to trail sensually up your arm. You noticed both Supreme Strange and Defender Strange had now entered the room as well. Defender Strange making sure to lock the door behind him.
Supreme Strange took his turn to speak and move towards the bed. He approached far more carefully than Sinister or Original Stephen. Only coming to stand at the foot of the bed, wanting your go ahead before entering your personal space.
"I think it is safe to say that we have all been toying with similar thoughts since shortly after we arrived. You're just that irresistible to all of us. Although we may have to set some ground rules."
Defender Strange smiled warmly and sat across from you. Like Supreme Strange he made sure to not get too close before he had your permission. All three other men looked at him waiting for him to speak. Had they already discussed this? There was no way they had been thinking this from the beginning, planning it the whole time, had they?
"The main rule is that this is all about you my sweet. The second is that you can change your mind at any time. We will attempt to share you as evenly as we can, but you can tell us to stop or if you decide you only want one of us or anything else at any time. Your wish is our command. The third is that we will be having as little contact with each other, or ourselves however you wish to see it, as we can. The last is that we won't start fighting, at least during this. We all promise."
He picked up your hand and kissed the back of it before placing it back down. Original Stephen directed your attention back to himself. Guiding you to sit in the middle of the bed. Making eye contact with you once you were settled.
"We need to hear you say yes sweetheart. If you have any rules of your own to add feel free to tell us. We all just want to please you. Do you want this? Do you want us?"
You were having a stroke. That had be what was going on. Or Rod Serling was about to come out, talk to an imaginary camera and announce you were in The Twilight Zone.
Eh fuck it, you were dating a sorcerer already anyway. If you were in The Twilight Zone it can't be much of a change from your normal life already. This was a once in a million lifetimes chance. Like hell you were gonna say no.
"Are you with us beautiful?" Supreme Strange was still standing at the footboard of the bed, but you could tell from his grip on it he was ready to vault over it towards you.
"Yeah. Yes, sorry I just got lost there for a second... If you guys really mean this. If you are really offering me this chance then. Yes. Yes, I want this so bad."
You could tell Sinister wanted to be the first to pounce on you, but Original Stephen shot him a look that told him he had to wait his turn. Your Stephen leaned in to kiss you deeply, you let his tongue slide into your mouth as soon as you felt his lick at your lips. His hands coming up to your face so he could tilt your head to the side and lower himself to lick at your ear and neck. Allowing Sinister Strange to attack your lips.
His kiss was far more desperate than Original Stephen's. He kissed you like he was trying to devour you. Biting your lower lip and grinning against you as let out a breathy more. The other two men took this opportunity to move in. Defender Strange grabbing one of your hands in both of his. Kissing your fingertips and palm before moving up to suck on the pulse point at your wrist. Supreme Strange had indeed crawled over the footboard and was caressing your legs moving up toward you.
Sinister Strange finally relinquished his assault on your lips when Supreme Strange made his was up your torso. Nudging his nose between your breasts over your clothes before bringing his face to yours. His kiss was very similar to Original Stephen but his smooth face made him stand out. He was sweet but firm and insistent. It didn't take long for him to break away and pull your shirt up over your head. He set right to work removing your pants as well. Anxious to feel your skin on his.
Defender Strange was the last to finally get to kiss you. Your hands immediately flew into his hair disrupting the smoothed back sides and letting one hand twirl into the length of his ponytail. You felt him chuckle as you played with it.
He whispered against your mouth as nuzzled his nose into yours, "I knew you'd been dying to play with my hair. Well now you can play with it all you want."
You gave it a firm tug and he groaned in pleasure. His fingertips digging into the soft flesh of your hips. It was then you noticed that Supreme Strange had gotten you down to just your bra and panties. The feeling of four sets of hands on your bare skin was setting your nerves ablaze. The sensation of Sinister Strange biting and sucking a bruise onto the top of one of your breasts made you moan and arch your back pushing you harder against his mouth.
Looking around you saw they had all taken the oppurmity to get themselves into various states of undress. Supreme Strange was shirtless and starting to work on removing his pants as he sat up on his knees between your legs. You quickly pushed his hands away and started undoing them yourself. Before pushing them down, you stuck one hand inside and gripped his half hard cock in your palm. Squeezing him and making him thrust lightly into your warm touch.
Original Stephen was down to his boxers, one hand rubbing at his growing erection as he watched you. He knew he was the one who would have ample time with you after tonight, so he was okay with sitting back and watching a little more than the others. It wasn't everyday he had the opportunity to watch himself fuck you.
Sinister Strange pulled your other hand back to his crotch and started grinding firmly against it. He was already fully erect and you gasped at just how hard he felt. He also felt like he was the largest so far. You sat up on your knees so you could split your attention more evenly. Original Stephen at your back and Defender Strange in front of you. While you stroked Supreme Strange with your right and Sinister Strange with your left.
Defender Strange began disrobing under your watchful eye. Seeing his muscular body start to be revealed inch by inch as he moved teasingly slowly. Original Stephen pressed himself to your back. His cock sitting firmly against your ass as he rocked himself into you. Reaching one hand around to rub at you over your panties. He leaned in to talk to you, his voice thick and gravely.
"Are you enjoying this sweetheart? All of our attention on you. You see how much we all want you. How hard we all are for yoy. Don't be afraid to tell us how good it feels."
He then slipped the hand that was between your legs into your panties. Dipping his fingers low enough to feel how wet you were. Teasing his fingers up and down your slit a few times before bringing it up to stroke your clit. As he did you started stroking the other two a little faster. Moans erupting from the three of you.
The sight of Defender Strange naked and stroking his long hard cock as he watched you making you grow wetter. You needed more of all of them and you needed it now. Your needy whimper echoing through the bedroom. You finally managed to groan out your request.
"Fuck. Need more."
You pushed your hips back into Stephen & he got the message quickly. He moved to pull your panties down and you flipped yourself onto your back letting him pull them off of you completely as you removed your bra. Supreme Strange signaling him to switch spots. Maybe they could read your mind after all.
Defender Strange moved to your head as the others finished stripping. You were quick to open your mouth and stick out your tongue to tell him what you wanted. He was all too happy to oblige by bringing his cock right to your lips. Letting your tongue lick at the underside of his cock before sucking lightly at the underside of his head.
Feeling the bed shift as Sinister & Original Stephen positioned themselves at your side's close to your head Your hands greedily reaching out for them before you leaned up so you could look at each of them. Sucking on the head of each of their cocks before pulling off with pop. After a few licks back & forth between the three you were already cock drunk & had spit running down your chin.
Laying your head back down you started stroking both Sinister and Original. Your saliva on their cocks noe adding a wet pornographic sound as you pumped them up and down. Defender Strange slapped his cock against your mouth several times. One of them creating a string of spit and pre-cum dripping from his tip and onto your lips. You licked it up before opening your mouth wide and letting him start to thrust into it.
He started shallow at first, bobbing just the sensitive head of his cock in past your lips. Before long he started pushing a little deeper. Inch by inch until you had to tilt your head back and press harder into the mattress to let him start fucking your throat.
Original Stephen moved to wipe away a tear that had slid from your closed eyes as you tried to keep breathing around the thick shaft stuffing your throat. You could practically hear his smile as he moaned at the sight of your trachea expanding and contracting. He was cooing sweet little praises as he watched you.
"That's my good girl. You're so good at sucking cock honey. You know it too. I see that look you get in your eyes."
"Such an insatiable little thing." Sinister Strange growled and slapped at one of your tits before leaning down to suck on the same one. Pulling off of you only to spit down on his own cock to add more lubrication for your fist. "You want to be our little whore don't you. Our needy little slut. Such a good little slut for us."
Suddenly you heard a voice from between your legs, you had forgotten Supreme Strange was down there. He bent your legs and pushed them open wide spreading your sopping wet cunt open to him. Each of the two men at your side's grabbing behind your knees to hold your legs in place, allowing Supreme Strange to rake his nails down the backs of your thighs. His hands coming to rest where he could pull your pussy open even farther for himself to enjoy.
Without any word he dipped down & let his tongue drag from the base of your entrance up to your clit, sucking it into his mouth briefly. You moaned & gagged around Defender Strange's cock at the feel of his warm wet tongue. He started lapping at your core, never letting his mouth stay in the same spot for long. Making sure to rub his soft cheeks and chin along your folds creating as much contact with every inch of your sweet sex he could reach. He nuzzled, licked, & sucked at you like you were the most delicious treat he had ever tasted.
Defender Strange pulled himself from your throat when he felt you start to lose your rhythm due to the tongue exploring your pussy. The choked out gasp as he pulled out made him groan. You hardly got a second to breath before Original Stephen kissed your lips hard, snaking his tongue into your mouth. Not minding the hint of foreign flavor that danced between you.
You took your hand off of his cock and wrapped it around his neck adding a little bit of extra intimacy between the two of you. He was the one of them you really fell for in the first place after all. He was enjoying every time Supreme Strange would lick you just right and elicit a moan to come through against his mouth. You were tempted to stay like this for a bit longer but you could feel Sinister starting to lose his patience at only having your hand.
So you pulled away and turned your attention to him, bringing your hand that wasn't already on his cock to grab his hip and pull him closer to your mouth. Just as you were about to take him in, Supreme Strange decided to plunge a finger inside you and start thrusting it. No doubt earning a glare for momentarily distracting you.
Defender Strange just seemed to be enjoying all the sounds you were making. He genuinely seemed to be interested in making sure they turned you into a shaking sobbing mess.
"Focus kitten! We can't have fucked you stupid already, we haven't even really gotten started yet. Now put that pretty little mouth to good use. If you need to moan you're gonna do it around my cock."
He grabbed your chin in his hand and pulled your face over so you were almost touching his flushed leaking tip. You purposely wanted to tease him a little. So you didn't move a muscle, you just looked up at him with wide eyes. Trying to look as innocent as you could naked with your legs spread and another man's face buried in your pussy. You could hear a snicker from one of the two men behind you. You weren't stupid. You knew that despite promising not to fight with each other they were still trying to best one another. They were all still Stephen Strange after all. Everything was a competition to prove that he was the best.
"Are you gonna be a bad girl for me when you were being so good before? Open up baby, stick out your tongue. You know you want my cock in your mouth. Come on, suck on it like a good girl."
You let him put your head forward enough to run his tip back and forth over your lips. After a few seconds you stopped to place a small sweet little kiss over the slit on the very tip. Slowly you repeated the kiss but each time letting your mouth open a little bit more, taking a little bit more of him in and sucking. Like he was a lollipop. It created a wet sucking pop every time you pulled back. One of the lewdest and sexiest sounds you had ever heard.
He let you play with him for a couple minutes before he gave you a look that said you better take a deep breath as he gathered your hair in his hand. He held your head in place and started harshly thrusting his hips forward. Fucking your throat as deep as he could. A guttural groan pulled from deep in his chest. Eventually bringing both his hands to the back of your head.
Once he got a steady rhythm you let go of his hips and reached out one hand towards Defender Strange to start stroking him. Your other hand finding Supreme Strange's hair. As he felt you grab a hold of it you felt his mouth and fingers speed up. Somewhere along the line he had slipped a second one into you. You felt the energy starting to build in your low belly signaling he had you close to cumming.
Sinister Strange felt your throat tighten as he fucked your face, but he only let up when he felt you starting shake in pleasure. The heat that had pooled shot out through your limbs and left you a moaning trembling mess. Supreme Strange started to slow his movements easing you down from your high. As his head emerged, his face was wet and flushed from bringing you to orgasm, you threw yourself towards him. Positioning yourself on all fours, you immediately started bobbing your head up and down his length.
The conversation behind you starting about who would get your pussy first. You were half listening. Splitting your attention between them and the moaning mess of a man above you. Momentarily you pulled off of Supreme Strange's cock to voice your input. Reaching one hand back towards the side you knew Original Stephen was on.
"If he wants it, he can have my ass too."
All four of them groaning and swearing at your statement. You knew you trusted him enough to do that. You weren't experienced enough with anal to feel comfortable letting any of the others. As caring as Defender Strange seemed, you still just didn't know him well enough. Supreme Strange honestly seemed perfectly content with your mouth, even though you were sure he'd want a turn to fuck you too. You felt Stephen press a kiss to your shoulder blade in acknowledgment of your intimate offering just for him.
"I've already called last too, sweetheart."
You could tell it was Defender Strange who won the debate. Feeling the tip of his cock slide up and down against your dripping sex before slowly starting to press into your hole. He moved painfully slowly, easing his way into you, wanting you to feel every inch he gave you. Every ridge and every vein. Holding you in place once he bottomed out. Once again the thought that you had not one but two of Stephen Strange balls deep inside you, one in your mouth and one in your cunt, made you shiver in pleasure. Your warm wet walls gripping Defender Strange tighter, making him start rutting himself into you slowly while staying buried deep.
"Wait wait! I have an idea, boys. Defender get on your back. I'm gonna ride you. Once I get a rhythm going I'm gonna lean flat against you and Supreme you are gonna come fuck me at the same time. I want both of your cocks in my pussy at once. You boys game? Sinister and Stephen I can either jerk you off or blow you until these two cum. Then you're up. Come on, need you to fuck me please! All four of you!"
You waggled your eyebrows at them. A couple of them looked shocked at your sudden dominance but they all scrambled to get in position. Defender Strange clearly happy as you sunk back down on his cock after positioning yourself on top of him. You leaned down brace yourself on the bed with one hand and used the other to play with his long hair, still in its ponytail but spread on the bed. His hands on your thighs massaging the soft flesh there. He moaned and whimpered as you worked your pussy on him. You could tell he was liking letting you use him.
"Does that feel good baby? Like it when I ride your cock? I think if the others weren't here you would just let me use you to get myself off wouldn't you?"
You dipped down to bite at his neck as you pulled his hair making him groan loudly. Just like in your fantasy. You were starting to move a little bit faster on him, your ass starting to slap against his thighs whenever you slid back down his shaft. Suddenly two large hands looped around you from behind and groped at your tits.
Supreme Strange pinched at your nipples as he kissed your neck. Smiling into your skin as he felt you shudder. He confessed his thoughts to you, "he's not the only one who would let you fuck him like your own personal toy."
You lifted your hand from Defender's hair, leaving the one resting on his chest for balance, and reached around behind you to wrap it around Supreme's neck. Turning your head to kiss him and feeling his cock slide up and down against your ass cheeks as you continued to bounce on Defender Strange.
"Yeah, is that right? Ready for me to play with you too? Think you can make your big cock fit in my little pussy? Gonna have to stretch me nice and slow baby. Let me pull off of him for a second so you can get nice and wet."
For a moment Defender Strange and Supreme Strange took turns. One sliding into you only to pull out and let the other fill you up. Making sure they were both well lubed up. Once you could tell your slick was well coating them both, you leaned forward and laid your chest against Defender Strange. Sticking your ass a little farther up in the air.
Defender Strange stayed buried inside you and didn't move as Supreme Strange started to probe against your already full hole. Starting with a single finger and then two before positioning the head of his cock there. He prodded his swollen leaking head against you softly and then a little firmer as he felt you starting to stretch open to accommodate him as well as Defender Strange. They weren't sure how thrilled they were that their dicks would be rubbing against each other, but as soon as they felt how incredibly tight and wet it was they soon stopped caring.
Stuffed with both of them you could never have imagined feeling so full, and they could never have imagined anything more tight.
Once Supreme Strange had managed to slide all the way inside you, the three of you stayed perfectly still for a moment. All trying not to cum instantaneously. The only sound you could make when Original Stephen asked if you were good was a high pitched squeak.
Supreme Strange had his forehead on your back and your face was buried in Defender Strange's neck when you finally started begging for one of them to move. Your hands had moved to grip the thighs of the men on your left and right. Sinister was growling deeply as he stroked himself while he waited for you to turn his direction so he could have your mouth. Stephen was busying cooing what a good girl you were and how fucking sexy you looked stuffed like that.
The two men fucking you started to work in tandem, letting Supreme start to move first before Defender Strange started slowly rolling his hips as opposed to thrusting. Letting him add more friction against your clit while his cock pressed back and forth toward your g-spot. Supreme Strange started thrusting a little bit faster, testing both your limits and the limits of the man under you that was also being stimulated by his movements. It wasn't long before the two of them struck a good rhythm. One of them thrusting in while the other pulled back. The wet slap of Supreme Strange's balls against you balanced by the wet squelching of Defender Strange's cock finding a way to dig impossibly deeper into your cunt.
Even though you knew it wouldn't take much more for you to cum again, you had enough of yourself pulled back together to take Sinister back into your mouth. Licking and sucking at him more gently this time, but it was enough for him to be happy. He looked down at you as you swirled your tongue around his tip, eyes closed and starting to space out from all the attention you were getting. He let his hand caress your cheek in a moment of softness.
Original Stephen was watching as the other three fucked you in utter astonishment that he was the one lucky enough to have gotten you in the first place. Not only that, but the fact that you were still saving something special just for him. He was having to temper his own movements so he wouldn't cum before he even got to fuck you. Just as he was starting to wish the other two would hurry up, their movements started to become more percussive.
Supreme Strange was starting to snap his hips against you a bit faster and rougher. His forehead dropped back down to the back of your neck and he started to place little bites along your shoulder blade. Snarling into your skin every time he felt your pussy clench around him. You were starting to whimper around Sinister Strange's cock.
"Oh fuck beautiful, I'm gonna cum. Where do you want me to cum?" His words came as broken little grunts. His eyes squeezed shut trying desperately to hold on until you could direct him.
"Inside me. Fuck please cum inside me. I want all four of you to cum in my pussy."
You pulled off of Sinister's cock just long enough to answer. Letting your tongue drop down to lick at his balls while you spoke.
Supreme Strange moaned as he let himself drive faster and faster into you. Defender Strange's breath was starting to come in more shallow bursts. He was determined to hold off until after you came again. The faster harder thrusts had your pussy starting to flutter around them and he knew only a couple more well placed rolls of his hips to hit your sweet spot would have you falling apart on top of him.
A deep grunt exploded from Supreme Strange, a noise coming from deep in his chest, as he slammed himself as deep in your cunt as he could. His hot seed starting to spill into you making you feel even fuller than you already were. His orgasm stretched out longer by the actions of Defender Strange's cock pushing the cum deeper into you and back against his spurting head. The feeling of Supreme Strange cumming inside you was what pushed you over into your second orgasm.
Your body started to convulse and shake. Your face pressed into Sinister Strange's abdomen. Drool still dripping from your mouth down onto his cock as you tried to hang on during the wave of orgasm. Before you could manage to come back down Defender Strange followed you & Supreme Strange by cumming hard. His nails digging into the flesh of your thighs as his cum started to shoot inside you. By the time he was finished you were completely overflowing. Their combined loads along with your slick dripping out of your hole around their shafts.
One at a time they slowly slid out, each with a sensitive hiss. Both making sure to kiss you deeply before moving back on the bed. Leaving plenty of room for the other two men to take their turn with you. You fell back down on your back between Original Stephen and Sinister Strange. Waiting for them to signal how they wanted you. Sinister Strange looming large over top of you staring down at you with hunger visible on his face.
He reached down between your legs and scooped up some of the spend leaking from you. The feeling of his fingers against your sensitive labia making you groan and shudder. He brought his fingers up to your lips and signaled for you to open your mouth. He wanted you to taste what you had done & suck his fingers clean.
As he felt your tongue lick over the pads of his fingers he pulled them from your mouth before popping them into his own. Moving to climb on top of you slotting himself between your legs. Gently sliding his cock up and down the slit of your swollen cunt. Tapping at your hypersensitive clit with his thick head.
"Now I get to have you all to myself for a moment before I have to share you with the good Doctor."
You looked over toward Stephen. He had positioned himself at your side. Clearly planning to join in once Sinister had repositioned you on your side. He was busy making sure he had everything ready to easily slip into your ass. Slipping on a condom, he would take that off when he was ready to finish in your pussy so he wouldn't have to stop in between, and starting to lube himself up.
The sight of him mixed with the wet erotic sound of his hand on his cock making you arch your back in anticipation. Sinister took this as his cue to push inside you. His cock sliding in effortlessly with the copious amount of your own arousal and cum lubricating you.
He brought his mouth to your neck as you looped your legs up over his hips. He bit and sucked bruises on the skin of your throat, pulling back to admire his handy work after leaving several marks. He purred his approval as he started thrusting in and out of you. Slow and smooth rocking of his hips quickly progressing to sharp and hard snaps as deep as he could.
"You have no idea how beautiful you are all marked up by us. Everyone should know who you belong to. You and this perfect pussy. Don't know how you are still so tight sweetheart, even after getting that pretty cunt stretched."
He started thrusting into you with a fervent speed. The whole bed rocking under the force he was using. He was also clearly enjoying being face to face with you. Taking his time and letting his tongue tangle with yours as he fucked you. He let himself get dangerously close to climax before stopping suddenly and rolling onto his side pulling you with him. He reached down to grab your top leg and pulled it up over the crook of his elbow. Opening you up even more as Original Stephen slid into position behind you.
Stephen let a single lubed up finger start to circle your tight asshole. Slowly adding more pressure until he could push it inside you. Repeating his actions with a second finger before moving them inside you to stretch you each direction. Sinister made sure you didn't move around too much since you were almost too far gone to even hold yourself in place. Placing teasing kissess on your skin and reminding you to tell them what was going on in your head.
"Stay with us kitten. I know you are getting fucked out but we still have to cum and I know we can pull at least one more orgasm from you. Does that feel good? Having me in your pussy while he plays with your ass?"
You moaned out a single "fuck" when you felt the head of Stephen's cock replace his fingers at your backdoor. Before starting to press himself in he kissed right below your ear and whispered to you, "just say the word if you need me to stop love."
An affirmative hum and head nod telling him you understood. He slowly and gingerly started pressing his head inside you as Sinister remained still buried deep in your cunt. Enjoying how your pussy squeezed him every time Stephen managed to push a little deeper into your ass. It was taking every ounce of self-restraint he had not to start driving hard into you every time you looked at him with those pretty little eyes ready to roll back in your head.
Eventually Stephen bottomed out inside you. The full feeling of having them both felt so different to the full feeling Supreme Strange and Defender Strange had given you, but they were both oh so good. Your hips started trying to move, urging one or both of the two men currently feeling you up to move. Sinister took that opportunity to pull almost all the way out of you before pushing himself all the way back in. A devilish grin across his face as he watched your eyes roll all the way back.
"Oh, my little pet, there's that fucked stupid look I've been dying to see on your face."
He pulled your hair into the hand he wasn't using to hold up your leg and started thrusting into you hard. Stephen stayed still for a few more beats until you placed a hand on top of his and giving it a squeeze. You needed him to move too. You didn't know how much longer you could last. You felt like your next orgasm might actually make you explode.
Sinister and Original Stephen began moving at the same time. Spearing you from both sides. Each thrust in nudging you closer to cumming. You started whimpering and crying that you were close. Stephen lowered his hand to rub your clit and stimulate you even more. All it took was a single statement more from Sinister to push you over the edge.
"Be a good little pet and cum on our cocks. Then we'll fill you up again. Give you four loads in that perfect cunt. Just what you wanted."
Your back arched hard and you came with a scream of pleasure. Only vaguely aware of the fluid gushing from you. Each thrust of the two men inside you coaxing another squirt from you until you were practically limp. You just hung on for dear life as the man at your front sped up to a nearly impossible rate. Yanking your hair to expose your neck and biting hard as he filled you. His teeth only releasing when his cock had stopped twitching inside you. Soothing the sore spot he left behind with a long wet lick.
Stephan had sneakily pulled out from your ass as Sinister Strange was coming down from his orgasm. He disposed of the used condom and wrapped his arms back around you from behind as Sinister Strange let you go from his grasp. You pulled your legs up and felt Stephen slide into your cunt in one smooth motion. You turned your head to nuzzle into his cheek and held onto his arm around your waist with the other.
He fucked you with a passion the others lacked. A familiarity and a comfort that made him stand apart. Even in your exhausted state he managed to coax a new set of moans and pleas from you. He twisted his body so he could press his forehead to yours. Placing soft sweet kisses in between whispers of, "so good sweetheart, so good."
His hips slowly speeding up and creating a hypnotic rhythm that before long had you squeezing his cock tightly. Sending you into a deep orgasm that thrumbed through your entire body, leaving your fingers and toes numb in it's wake. His own orgasm cresting with yours as he spilled inside of you. Your breath and heart rates hitting their height together before coming back down.
He gently eased himself out of your body and laid down on the bed carefully arranging your body on top of his. Holding you and letting your head come to rest on his shoulder. You were no longer mentally present. Just a babbling, moaning mess from how hard you had just been fucked. The five of you lay at various angles on the bed and the hands of the other three men occasionally stroked a portion of exposed skin on your body. Petting you like a cat and telling you how good you were for them. Even in your blissed out state you keened at their praises.
They studied the state of your body. Lots of bruises and love bites. Your pussy swollen, leaking cum, & sore. The muscles of your arms and legs felt like Jello under their fingers. One at a time the three variants stood and began moving around the room and the adjoining bathroom. Redressing themselves and preparing a warm bath for you. They would leave your Original Stephen to care for you.
They all came over to the bed one more time and placed at least one more kiss on your lips before leaving. Some of them also placed one on your forehead or the back of your hand. Similar to how they had entered, Defender Strange was the last to leave and he made sure to pull the door shut behind him and re-locked it with his magic from the other side.
Stephen stood and scooped you up, carrying you into the bathroom. Placing you into the bath before climbing in behind you. He washed the both of you and let you relax on his lap in the warm water until it had thoroughly cooled. You were a little more coherent now but still clung to him like a koala bear. He didn't mind. He made that clear by nuzzling his face into your hair and kissing you over and over.
After drying you both he carried you back to bed. The sheets had been magically changed while the two of you were gone. Initially laying you down before trying to dress himself to leave. You quickly reached for any part of his body you could grab. Desperately wanting him to spend the night with you. You had so missed waking up next to him.
"Stephen, please stay with me. I missed getting to be alone with you."
He smiled brightly. Not only had you chosen four of him, you had chosen him specifically. While he didn't mind sharing you once with different versions of himself, he never wanted to share you with anyone else again. Frankly, as fast as he was falling for you he would be hard pressed to share you with himself again either.
He happily crawled into the bed with you and let you cuddle into him. "Of course darling. I'll stay as long as you'll have me."