Pugglecake
Recent bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
“Now,” Arthur sighs, a bone weary sound. He settles in closer to John, enough to smell the pomade in his hair and the stale perfume of day-old laundry. “Where’s hurtin’, sweetheart?”
Arthur and Sadie break John out of prison, and Arthur cares a hell of a lot more than he lets on.
Bookmarked by Pugglecake
28 Jan 2026
-
I'm Sorry, But You Knew That by orphan_account
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
23 Jun 2022
Tags
Summary
"Johnny," Arthur murmurs, sitting up a bit, "Don't you wanna know?"
"Know what?" John shifts and refuses to look down, hoping and praying the bulge of his cock isn't obvious in his drawers.
"If you like fellas?"
"I- Shit, Arthur, alright, I do," John huffs, "I already know I do, you ain't gotta-"
John gestures widely at Arthur's nakedness.
"Taunt me like this," John whispers.
"... Ain't tauntin' you," Arthur says slowly.
Bookmarked by Pugglecake
25 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
“What ‘bout you?” Arthur asks quietly as he strokes the bottom few inches of his length while John’s fingers cradle the head.
John leans his hips forward against the wagon.
It doesn’t help much, the hard, unrelenting wood, but it’s a solid thing to press against.
He feels his face flushed bright and hot as he avoids Arthur’s eyes.
“C’mon, you wanna repay me?” Arthur whispers, “Tell me.”
Bookmarked by Pugglecake
24 Jan 2026
-
You call me the jealous type, but darlin' that ain't true by por_queeee
Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)
22 Feb 2024
Tags
Summary
“I’m not jealous of them, Marston.” A wad of spit hits the ground to the right of John’s head and he sneers. “I'm embarrassed for you.”
Arthur's not giving him the time of day, so John distracts himself elsewhere. There are consequences.
Bookmarked by Pugglecake
24 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
John lays down stiffly next to him and Arthur sighs roughly, only to feel John stiffen further, wiggle as far away as he can.
"... I ain't gonna bite you."
"You need more room than I do."
"I mean, yeah, that might be true but you ain't gotta… You can spread out a lil', that can't be comfortable."
"Arthur, none of this is comfortable."
"Have… Have you never shared a bed before?"
John's resounding silence answers him, embarrassed and loud despite John not protesting.
Bookmarked by Pugglecake
24 Jan 2026