mustard34
Recent bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
“Yes!” He extends his hand. “Nice to meet you, Ms Matthews, I assume?”
She chuckles then crinkles her nose. “Oh god, don’t call me Ms, it makes me feel old,” she teases with a smirk, showing a pair of fangs that Nat finds oddly adorable. “Charlotte or Lottie is fine,” she replies, shaking his hand.OR
the !poolboy nat au you've all been waiting for :3
Bookmarked by mustard34
30 Apr 2026
-
Tags
Summary
“For the last fucking time, Matthews, I am not goth!”
or, charlotte “lottie” matthews, the campus serial heartbreaker, loses a bet and has to prove that she can make any girl in uni fall in love or sleep with her and her bumbling idiot friends choose natalie scatorccio, her estranged high school crush, with whom she had an unacknowledged homoerotic friendship.
or,
“I bet my dignity that I can beat your asses in beer pong, just me, solo.”
And that was how Charlotte Matthews got her ass colossally served to her by who she thought were her brothers (or sisters) in arms, Tai and Van.
What she wasn’t prepared for was what followed.
“Alright, Matthews. Since you oh so humbly bet your dignity, we dare you to either sleep with or successfully get into a relationship with a girl on campus of our choosing.” Van trailed off, while she raised her eyebrows.
“This is what the big deal is all about?”
“Well, yes!” Taissa proudly puffed her chest. “Because we chose Nat.”
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 64,517
- Chapters:
- 5/5
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 38
- Kudos:
- 352
- Bookmarks:
- 79
- Hits:
- 11,173
Bookmarked by mustard34
28 Apr 2026
-
Tags
Summary
It starts with a harmless lie. A simple “We’re dating” to avoid nosy questions. But things start to spiral when Lottie's friends buy into it.
Natalie and Lottie get stuck pretending to be in a relationship, all while navigating their casual, no-strings-attached fling. As the pressure builds and the lines between fake and real blur, they’re forced to confront feelings neither saw coming.
Series
- Part 1 of Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 341,404
- Chapters:
- 17/17
- Comments:
- 363
- Kudos:
- 1,054
- Bookmarks:
- 181
- Hits:
- 42,266
Bookmarked by mustard34
27 Apr 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Lottie Matthews has many secrets. One of which is her unhealthy obsession with a certain camgirl.
When one night Lottie is face to face with the woman she’d been drooling over for the past couple of months online, she finds herself adding to her list of secrets.
Unfortunately for Lottie, the truth always comes out.Or, Lottie meets camgirl Nat but remains secretive about her true identity as one of Nat’s viewers. Angst and Smut heavy
Bookmarked by mustard34
23 Apr 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Lottie Matthews was finally okay. Nat had left her a year ago and things were finally okay.
That was until she noticed a shaggy blonde mullet at a bar.
Tumblr request: "G!p Nat getting Lottie pregnant after a hook-up."Bookmarked by mustard34
14 Apr 2026