1 - 20 of 79 Works in Bisexual Jay Gatsby
Navigation
Listing Works
-
The Great Gaysby by Witches_Briar
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby (2013), The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
04 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
What if...
What if Tom and Daisy got consequences for their actions? If George don't listen to Tom, and decided to follow his original train of thought?
What if the aftermath is a much, much different story. One that would take a bit till it ends on a truly good note for all remaining parties.
Well, my dear readers, this story will explore this possibility and road. Hopefully,Series
- Part 1 of Old Assignments Rewritten
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 353
- Chapters:
- 1/?
- Kudos:
- 2
- Hits:
- 29
-
10 Inaccurate Conclusions by Nick Carraway by Donteatbatteries
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
12 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
After breaking up with Jordan, Nick tries to avoid thinking about why... while his neighbor has been growing increasingly strange in their every interaction.
...
This is a reimagining of "5 Times Jay Gatsby Failed to Seduce Nick Carraway" from Nick's pov and then assumes a continuation of the story where they navigate their relationship and both come to plenty of incorrect conclusions about what's being said. They're really bad at communicating.Reading the first story is not NECESSARY to understand this one, but I recommend it, because it makes this one much funnier.
Series
- Part 2 of Wet Cat Jay Gatsby
-
The Beautiful And The Buried by maraudersmqry
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (2013)
31 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
A year after George Wilson is sentenced for the attempted murder of Jay Gatsby, the glittering world of champagne-soaked nights and murmured affairs continues undisturbed—untouched by the violence that nearly shattered it. But Nick Carraway is no longer the man he was. Against his better judgment—and despite every defense he’s tried to rebuild—he’s been changed by what was lost, and by what he still refuses to name.
Caught between memory and desire, Nick grapples with an affection that defies logic, with feelings for Jay that don’t fit the life he thought he understood. It isn’t just love he’s afraid of—it’s the possibility that it was always there, quietly waiting beneath every long glance and late-night confession.
-
To Love Alone by Connor_014
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby (2013), The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (1974)
11 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
This takes place just after Daisy attends her first party at Gatsby’s.
Nick hears a commotion over at Gatsby’s and chooses to investigate.I mixed both the book and the movie together so its more of my own interpretation than anything else.
-
more natsby by BarricadeEnthusiast
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (Musical)
07 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
Based on a few headcanons from a tiktok mutual!!!!! i suck at writting im so sorry guys
Look Gatsby didnt go around saying he was "Shellshocked" or whatever his psychatrist told him, those memories were shoved neatly into a box in his mind. Well until the past finally catches up to him. After Tom and Gatsby argue, Daisy and Tom leave the party leaving Gatsby alone to ponder just a moment.
super slow updates... heh... slso this is gonna be MULTICHAPTER WHATTTT
-
gatsby and the goose by wistfulenchantress
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
26 Jun 2025
Tags
Summary
The Great Gatsby soulmate goose of enforcement au/fix-it fic because I cannot be stopped.
-
The Gayest Ivy by Miscellaneous_mess
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby (2013), The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
08 Jun 2025
Tags
Summary
A proud banner over the table read ‘The Gayest Ivy’. Jay didn't know if that was true.
~~~
Nick didn't look like a girl to Jay, but then Jay supposed that was probably what Nick was going for. His chest was pressed flat and while his jawline and eyes had a soft sort of femininity to it, his other features were sharp. Jay felt a sort of flutter, Nick was beautiful but not in the same way he had ever found a girl beautiful before.
-
Tags
Summary
it won't let me add my own tags !!
Basically I rewrote the book in Jordan's lesbian perspective! In which Nick and Jordan team up to break up Daisy and Toms marridge while pretending to be a couple. Because let's be real they're lavender marridge material. Very very gay because happy pride !!Trust me I did the alevel.
-
Tags
Summary
“ I expect that this will remain the only retelling of what happened the night before Gatsby’s death, and I would hope for both of our sakes that it remains that way in eternity.”
***
There is a version of chapter eight that lives in Nick Carraway’s desk drawer, for good reason; it is the true events of the night in which their relationship shifted, for better or for worse. -
Nick is Gay and I'll Stand By It (Title to be changed) by Tony_Not_Stark420
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby (2013), The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby - Howland/Tysen/Kerrigan
30 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
The Great Gatsby but Nick and Gatsby get together and there isnt just sexual tension the whole time. I also shove in as many tropes as possible. You're welcome.
First chapter is an assignment I wrote for Englsih class thats why its bad. The others will be better and longer I swear.
-
The Unreality of Reality by spir6ling
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby (2013), The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
27 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
Gatsby believed in the green light that was almost in his grasp. But Nick yearns to be his green light.
Then Nick falls ill and all changes for the better.
-
an elaborately designed privately owned spiral galaxy by drecantread
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (2013)
26 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
"Hello again, old sport," as if that charming smile—the one he'd given him on a foggy morning as he'd drawn him in for a slow kiss—wasn't enough, he rasped out that stupid nickname he'd use for everyone. That stupid nickname that had turned into my love, but now-
Nick cleared his throat and finally found his voice, "It really is you." His eyes were searching Jay's, looking for any indication that whatever they had had wasn't yet over. That there was still a chance he could bring him in for a kiss and would't instead hear I'm sorry. It's over now. I need to return to my girl, like he had that last time.or
nick and gatsby were in the same troupe in the great war, parted ways and met again at west egg
-
Where do we go from here? by Quillbot_7000
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
12 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
after Tom and daisy ditch Gatsby, nick helps him out.
and maybe he realizes he had a crush on him all along. -
Rewrite of the Stars by tobi_lee08
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby (2013), The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
04 Mar 2025
Tags
Summary
What if Gatsby lived? What if he ran away with Nick?
A new love blooms after the events of that tragic summer in New York. As they are rebuilding their life, someone new comes along to reck all the progress made -
A Tale of Growth (A Gayer Marxist Gatsby) by Mysterious_lil_goblin
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
07 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
Esentually I didn't like the Daisy Buchanan bashing and decided to rewrite The Great Gatsby. Will Gatsby and Nick actually get together? Who knows but there will be a lot of pinning.
Spoiler Alert both Gatsby and Myrtle still die.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 1,519
- Chapters:
- 1/10
- Bookmarks:
- 1
- Hits:
- 58
-
Tags
Summary
*Spoilers for the Great Gatsby*
Starting where the 2013 movie ends, Jay Gatsby wakes up after his traumatic injury to find his friend Nick Carraway waiting for him. As Jay recovers from his injury, the two grow closer than they had been before, and feelings start to develop.
(All chapters are inspired by a Noah Floersch song, as well as the title for this fic!)
-
My Love, I Lied to You by reluctantlyryn
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
26 Sep 2024
Tags
Summary
A distraught Jay Gatsby appears at Nick Carraway’s doorstep with something to discuss.
-
A Wisp of Startled Air by medievalbiscuit09
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
22 Sep 2024
Tags
Summary
What if Nick cut out a more... personal part of his final interactions with Gatsby the same way he did with Mr. McKee?
This is the "They're a rotten crowd" conversation reimagined, plus the fallout (aka a very long conversation in a train).
-
Tags
Summary
Jay has slowly realized something over the past two years since Daisy hasn't been the primary objective in his life, and he finally takes a step toward achieving happiness.
Series
- Part 1 of Jay Gatsby's Love Life
-
When I Realized by CowPriestess
Fandoms: The Great Gatsby (2013), The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
10 Aug 2024
Tags
Summary
This is the night where Nick realizes how he feels about Gatsby after seeing him watching the green light in the dock.
Series