1 - 20 of 59 Works in Reader is a Proxy (Slender Man Mythos)
Navigation
Listing Works
-
why are you so mean? by Jeff666
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets, Everyman HYBRID, Tribe Twelve
17 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
Toby message you because he have something to show you... something you might be interested in. He's an asshole, he often insults you in german worse than he would do to an enemy, but in the end he's often useful, so you don't complain.
I've included two characters from Tribe Twelve and Everyman Hibryd in the story to add some spice to the plot, trying to stay as canonical as possible about the Observer and Habit based on what I know from watching the series and reading the plot online. -
Tags
Summary
You hate Toby Rogers. Hate. He’s immature, and whiny, and gets in your way more often than not. Proxies are meant to work together, but you two just don’t. Fights are prone to happen, but when your hands accidentally find his throat, Toby accidentally finds out that he likes it. You hate him. And he hates you. So why can he suddenly not jerk off without thinking about your hands on his neck? Why does he want you to do it again??
-
Tags
Summary
You're just a tired college student trying to write a paper on some online urban legends.
What happens when some of those legends turn out to be very real, and very invested in making you work for them?(First part in a choose-your-own-romance series)
Series
- Part 1 of Bleeding Hearts
-
𝐒𝐚𝐲𝐨𝐧𝐚𝐫𝐚 𝐟𝐮𝐜𝐤𝐞𝐫 [BEING REWRITTEN DISCONTINUED] by HEARTSFORVIVI
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
12 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
𝘊𝘳𝘦𝘦𝘱𝘺𝘱𝘢𝘴𝘵𝘢 𝘹 𝘍!𝘳𝘦𝘢𝘥𝘦𝘳
𝐒𝐚𝐲𝐨𝐧𝐚𝐫𝐚 𝐟𝐮𝐜𝐤𝐞𝐫𝐒𝐔𝐌𝐌𝐀𝐑𝐘: 𝐎𝐡 𝐧𝐨!! 𝐑𝐨𝐦𝐚𝐧𝐜𝐞 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐤𝐢𝐥𝐥𝐞𝐫 𝐫𝐨𝐛𝐨𝐭𝐬?! Y/N, L/N is a loner who spends her time building a robot unaware of a certain faceless man who finds intrest in her little "project."
<𝟑
-
Tags
Summary
In a world full of nothing but misfortune. We often look toward comfort to remind us how to appreciate pain. Perfectionism is born from a lack of control. A need to feel order when you know there is no such thing. The man made dream for a perfect life is infectious. Like a disease, spreading to those around you. Or maybe you should just take up gardening?
(After extensive analysis I have discovered. Slender is my kink. I will not apologize.)
(This is not entirely accurate to the characters, this is honestly kind of a crack fic. I used the Rob Zombie films as inspiration so there will be references.)
*READ AT YOURE OWN RISK IT GETS BAD* -
Tags
Summary
You were abandoned by the Proxy whom you thought of as family, and tried to live a relatively normal life. Four years go by of this mundane living - you work, you eat, you listen to music, and you try to do self discovery meditations - when the life you thought left you behind comes barreling back at you. Your contract is unfinished, your absence was unplanned, you can’t fully be rid of the Slenderman’s influence.
(First Creepypasta Fanfiction in over six years, bare with me now) -
Tags
Summary
Y/N. Y/N hated everything about everything. In her angsty teen fit of rage, she ran away from home, into the forrest in hopes to find Slenderman. Instead she found something much worse.
WARNINGS: smut, angst, mentions of suicidal thoughts and SH. If any of that triggers you PLEASE DO NOT READ.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 309
- Chapters:
- 1/?
- Kudos:
- 8
- Hits:
- 158
-
Jeff the Killer x Slenderman by k1llj0ys_m4k3_sum_n01s3_XP
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Slender Man Mythos
18 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
For years, Jeff the Killer endured the torment of the man he both loved and could never claim. His suffering festered into obsession, until months of meticulous planning finally gave birth to a reality drowned in blood, where no soul remained untouchable. From the fissures of Hell, abominations crawled forth to serve his hidden purpose, yet the weave of fate shifted unexpectedly, binding both Jeff and Slenderman to a destiny neither could escape.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 5,714
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Kudos:
- 1
- Hits:
- 77
-
Tags
Summary
After a complete failure of a mission, you and your current assigned group return back to your less than ideal shelter to regroup. But that night when you fall asleep and wake up in a seemingly completely different world where everything is all sunshine and rainbows, you have to face the fact that there was a version of you living the good life while you were stuck suffering with a bunch of assholes. In your frustration you can't help but wish the worst upon that version of yourself, but maybe you should be careful what you wish for.
...What's going on back in your universe anyway?
-+-
GN!Reader Inserts x Various
--> Chapter 3 out now!
-
Dont treat burns with lukewarm water by creepypancakes
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
26 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
wake up. ignore it. go to school. come home. sleep.
this is your routine. this has been been your routine for years. the routine in your mostly mundane life that has kept you sane.
But when the pot boils over, you’ll get burned trying to grab it off the stove. But in your case what else are you supposed to do? let it sizzle over and spill onto the floor?
things are changing, and your bound to panic.
especially when your life slowly progresses to a turning point that you wont be able to undo.
How do you deal with the molten pot of your hallucinations becoming more and more real, when you get caught in the middle of a missings persons case?-
-
Tags
Summary
Returning from a mission, the proxies get caught in a bad storm, causing them to seek refuge in a dingy motel. They’re rain-soaked, irritable, and—even better—there’s only one bed. They agree to keep it civil… until the storm knocks the power out, and you find yourself growing very cold.
-
The Past Is Right Behind You by Raine_Drops
Fandoms: Marble Hornets, Slender Man Mythos, Creepypasta - Fandom
17 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
Tim runs away after the end of Marble Hornets and ends up in Colorado
Brian is alive after being revived by the Operator, and starts searching for Tim, where he finds Toby and eventually the Reader
Unfortunately, you can't run from fate. And running from your past works just as well, though that never stops anyone does it?Series
- Part 1 of Slenderverse Murder Trio
-
The Quiet Violence Of Wanting by rainrot4me
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
28 Jun 2025
Tags
Summary
Helplessness, guilt, remorse, and isolation—all unacceptable emotions when you’re a proxy. You’ve got blood on your hands, and purposeful or not, the cops don’t care. Their job is so take you in. It’s okay to need saving—especially if it’s from a pretty killer lady who’ll do anything to make you squeal.
-
Nothing Good Starts in a Getaway Car by your_friendly_neighborhood_fictophiliac
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
16 Jun 2025
Tags
Summary
The air smells of hot Cheetos, death, and regret. But you can't stop and take it in for too long though. You have to keep moving, lest your serial-killer ex or demon ex-boss catch wind of your trail.
You'd grown complacent to the life of a proxy. That was until that pregnancy test you took for shits and gigs stared back at you with two lines. Vowing to never put a child through that Hell and Misery, destined for the life of a proxy, you do the only thing you know to do: haul ass outta there. But the Operator doesn't like giving up its murder puppets up so easily, however and your ex has a history of tracking you in his sleep.
The mix of Slender Sickness and Morning Sickness sure make for one hell of a roadtrip. The smell of your hitchhiker in the trunk doesn't help things either. That's Steve. He's just sleeping. Don't worry about him.
After all... you got other things to worry about.
-
Tags
Summary
After Slender man works you to the bone, taking advantage of your ability to quickly track down targets with ease, you find yourself stressed out. It doesn't help that you've been stuck with the proxies on various mentally trying missions nearly every day. This, and all of the chaos that goes on in the mansion has only left you extremely overstimulated and tired out. Toby takes note and spend the day taking care of you.
-
Tags
Summary
Request work!
"In summary, a story with any of the creepypastas x f!reader. Specifically in the Slendermansion, and, can the reader be a new proxy? I don't care where the story goes, I just NEED creepypasta works, please, I'm starving!"- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 1,336
- Chapters:
- 1/?
- Kudos:
- 7
- Hits:
- 97
-
Tags
Summary
Toby finds out your secret and now you have to make sure he doesn’t run his mouth to his friends.
Series
- Part 1 of My Creepypasta/Slenderverse works !
-
Your Little Troublemaker by Definitely_derangeddd
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Slender Man Mythos
12 May 2025
Tags
Summary
‼️🪦🕊️ Do not eat🚫
—————
“You see a lot of yourself? In me?” He taunted snidely, biting his lower lip to stifle laughter.He relished in being a deviant, in front of you was no exception of course. he wasn’t about to just let you have your way with ‘apologising’ without making himself seem rude and completely uncooperative first.
Your lips pressed further into a unimpressed, fine line as you eyed Toby,watching the teen twisting his torso to face towards you.
Leaning off the edge of his seat like a petulant child..
Your eyes darted to where he sat, perched practically on the edge of the mangy sofa seat whilst he crept closer.“Toby, gross.” You twitched.
“Can't you just let me apologise?”“-And listen to you rant about your ‘back in my day’ bullshit? Nah..”
-------
Or:You (reader, in your early forties) and Toby (seventeen) spend the night together at a motel after a somewhat unsuccessful assignment. A small argument ensues and he pines over you during your poor apology.
‼️Read tags‼️
-
Tags
Summary
Y/n l/n is a fucked up teenager just trying to get though school and life, which isn't easy having a whore of a mother and a father they've never met while trying to push down their fucked up thoughts to fit into this shitty hell, after a attempted suicide their life turns even more shitty now having to learn to really live surrounded by killers.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 1,461
- Chapters:
- 1/19
- Kudos:
- 3
- Hits:
- 95
-
Savior || Eyeless Jack x GenderNeutral Reader by mangiferamango
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
05 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
You escape the facility that held you captive all your life only to be recaptured by the Slenderman. You have no choice but to adjust to your new life as a proxy, however it feels as though a large target has been placed on your back.
***
Inspired by “Eyeless Jack x Reader” by ThePerfectBlur on Wattpad. If you enjoy 2019 style Creepypasta fanfics, I encourage you to read it!