1 - 20 of 658 Bookmarks by Pyroshroom
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
Molly isn’t dead, but he could be having a better day. Caleb’s seen worse, but still isn’t thrilled. After the Glory Run Road, the Mighty Nein pick up the pieces.
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
16 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Molly once claimed he came from a cult. No, not just that. He claimed he escaped from a cult. They didn’t believe him then, what with his tendency for tall tales, but now...Caleb wishes he had listened closer.
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
15 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
"Molly was never under any illusion that he was going to live to a ripe old age. The circumstances of his life were too strange and riddled with pitfalls."
1. Molly
2. Caleb
3. YashaBookmarked by Pyroshroom
14 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Cree is the one who brings Molly back to life. Cree takes him back to the Gentleman and, in payment for her loyal service, the Gentleman helps Cree hide Molly's return from the rest of the Mighty Nein, and helps her in her efforts to find a way to make him remember Lucien's life.
When all her efforts fail, Cree washes her hands of Molly entirely rather than continue to be confronted with the utter ruin of her dreams and plans, and the Gentleman makes a little gold in making Molly disappear.
The rest of the Nein eventually find out, and come running to the rescue. From there, the team is there to pick up the pieces as Molly wonders what it means to be Mollymauk Tealeaf, and wonders if he even has that in him anymore.
(Written for the Mollymauk Lives Fest, Day 5, prompt "fortune")
Series
- Part 5 of Mollymauk Lives Fest
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 5,206
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 16
- Kudos:
- 357
- Bookmarks:
- 58
- Hits:
- 2,569
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
14 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Caleb has suffered quietly for months, but his hanahaki disease is entering the final stages. The night his secret gets out, he's left grappling for a way to either confess his feelings or muster up the courage to cure himself and render the matter a moot point.
To his surprise, Molly turns out to have some secrets too, and he's willing to trade if only to keep Caleb from hurting himself.
(Written for Widomauk Week 2019, Day 8, prompt "flowers")
Series
- Part 8 of Widomauk Week
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
13 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Caleb and Mollymauk are the only ones of the Mighty Nein at the Leaky Tap one night, when Caleb notices that a stranger seems to have designs on sleeping with Molly whether Molly wants it or not. Caleb must swallow down his fears of drawing attention in order to save his teammate from harm, but that still leaves as him the only one available to look after Molly as he sweats and suffers through the poison that was put in his drink for the sake of making him an easier target.
In the depths of his fevered delirium, Molly admits some things - about his life, about his past - that Caleb knows he would never truly want to say or want anyone else to hear. But all Caleb can do is listen, try to ease the sickness, and reflect on what a burden understanding can sometimes be.
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
13 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
The Mighty Nein finally return to Glory Run Road with the strength and materials needed to resurrect Mollymauk Tealeaf.
They find to their horror that he can't be brought back because his soul is not free to return.
After a bit of research, they find out who's keeping it sealed away, then delve down into the Abyss to murder the culprit and recover Molly's soul, setting him free from Lucien's deal. After one more resurrection research and a bit more research, they find out that a happy ending still might not be as easy as all that.
Caleb and Yasha take Molly to Nicodranus to recover from his ordeal. Caleb recognizes his old feelings rekindling, and starts to dream again of confessing them.
(Written for Widomauk Week, Day 1, prompt "reunion".)
Series
- Part 1 of Widomauk Week
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
13 Feb 2026
-
we're still so young, desperate for attention by floralprintshark
Fandoms: Critical Role (Web Series)
28 Mar 2018
Tags
Summary
Five times Beau tries to flirt with Yasha and one time Yasha flirts back.
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
12 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
The man sneers. “Her kind are nothin’ but bloodthirsty. You know that, right?” He looks at Molly like he expects an answer, like this is a reasonable thing to say.
Molly stays absolutely still.
Then: “Little demons, the lot of them.”
And all of the warmth drops out of Molly’s gut. Then he’s leaning in and his hand is fisted tight in the front of the man's shirt
****
or: Molly's night is not going the way he planned it.Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
12 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
“Is it easier?” Caleb’s voice cuts through his, steadier now than it was before. From the flash-bang intensity of it, the words had been burning a hole in Caleb’s tongue for some time. Though he suspects he knows the rest of the question, Molly waits to hear it out, his eyes tracing over the ball of Caleb’s thumb. "Not remembering?"
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
12 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Caleb doesn’t know what this is. He’d thought it would be a good way for Nott and him to hide, to shake off unwanted attention but it’s grown beyond that into something he can no longer control.
Series
- Part 1 of Works in Progress
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
11 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
They just don’t have time for anything now. They need to find their friends, or they need to find a way out. It is time to hurtle pell-mell through these caverns or die trying.
Really, fuck this place. Mollymauk officially hates it now.
aka Caleb and Molly get separated from the party with little to no supplies, it's cold and wet and the caves may just be trying to kill them (plus feelings)
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
11 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Caleb gave him that soft smile again, and perhaps it was a good thing Molly was now leaning against a piece of furniture. “I don’t think either of us would be much fun to dance with right now, Mister Mollymauk. And besides,” he looked at the minstrels, “I feel like a song, tonight.”
Series
- Part 4 of kisses are a far better fate than wisdom
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 3,701
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 13
- Kudos:
- 216
- Bookmarks:
- 22
- Hits:
- 1,512
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
10 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Molly can’t remember the first time he noticed Caleb’s hands.
Now, after the months of traveling together, the only thing he knows is that he can’t stop thinking about them.
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
10 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Yasha never expected to get close to anyone ever again after Zuala. She couldn't predict the purple tiefling.
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
09 Feb 2026
-
All that Blood was never once Beautiful by hideyourfires
Fandoms: Critical Role (Web Series)
19 Apr 2018
Tags
Summary
“If you won’t let me help,” He hisses, “Why are you telling me this?”
When he first met Molly, Caleb had found it difficult to decipher his facial expressions. Everything else about him had been too distracting, too many bright colours and bits of dangling jewellery. There was too much of him, all at once, and Caleb hadn’t known what to make of it.
Since then, he has learned to see through it. He knows now that that is its purpose; to distract. Because sometimes, sometimes, Molly looks very young, and vulnerable, and afraid.
Molly looks up at him, suddenly small, his lips a thin line.
“I don’t want be alone,” He says.
Series
- Part 1 of All that Blood was never once Beautiful
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
10 Feb 2026
-
meet me at midnight (for no other hour is open to lovers in stories like ours) by grayintogreen
Fandoms: Critical Role (Web Series)
24 Jan 2022
Tags
Summary
Sehanine is the Lady of Dreams, the goddess of mischief, creativity, and revelry, but also the protector of moonlit trysts, who hides secret lovers in her shadows and bathes them in moonlight when they need her glow.
And like all gods, she picks favorites.
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
09 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
In Molly's absence, and subsequent return, Caleb had forgotten how squishy he really is, and that scares him shitless. (not as deep as the title might lead you to believe, just caleb doing something he should have done a while ago)
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
08 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
On moonless nights Molly can't sleep.
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
08 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
She opens her mouth to say something insulting, like a reflex to respond to everything he says combatively, but something about that sentence gives her pause. It almost sounds like something that Lucien might say, but it’s also just to the left of being fully in character. Lucien rarely talks about Molly like he’s anything more than a speck, if he even acknowledges him at all. That kind of thing seems to imply he recognizes Molly as a full-fledged person.
She locks her eyes on Lucien’s eyes and she swears- she swears- she sees him squirm before he shakes his head and blinks.
That fucker never blinks.
Bookmarked by Pyroshroom
07 Feb 2026